55 4. COMMENTS FROM THE ITALIAN AUTHORITIES AND THE INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES › 4.1. Comments from the Italian authorities and the 78 interested parties › 4.1.2. ICI: the measure is justified by the logic of the Italian taxation system, Decision_act (EU) 2013/284

In forcesince 19 Dec 2012

As regards the objective requirement (i.e. performing one of the activities listed by the legislation), the Italian authorities pointed out that the Italian Court of Cassation has repeatedly held that, for the purposes of granting the ICI exemption, it is essential to consider the activity actually carried on in the real estate. This means checking that this activity, even if it is included in the list of exempted activities, is not actually pursued on a commercial basis [See judgments Nos 20776 of 26 October 2005, 23703 of 15 November 2007, 5485 of 29 February 2008 and 19731 of 17 September 2010. See also judgment No 8495 of 9 April 2010.]. In addition, as already established by the Council of State [See Opinion No 266 of 18 June 1996.], if only part of an entire property (even if it is the largest part) is used for one of the purposes allowed by the law, the restrictive nature of the exemption is such that the tax relief cannot be granted to the whole property.