196 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.5. Recovery › 6.5.2. Exceptional circumstances: absolute impossibility of recovery, Decision_act (EU) 2013/284

In forcesince 19 Dec 2012cited 1×

As regards tax databases, and in particular records of the tax declarations of non-commercial entities, Italy explained that it was possible to identify from them only the real estate used exclusively on a non-commercial basis. In this case, the buildings that produce revenue must be indicated in the standard tax declaration under Section RB on building revenue, whereas Section RS on mixed costs and receipts does not have to be filled in. On the other hand, if a non-commercial entity owns real estate in which commercial activities are also carried on, then both Sections RB and RS have to be filled in. However, if more than one building is indicated under Section RB, it is not possible to identify the real estate in which the activity that generated the revenue indicated in the tax declaration was carried on. In any case, it should be noted that Section RS of the standard form includes aggregate cost and revenue data concerning goods and services used for both commercial and non-commercial purposes (goods and services used arbitrarily for commercial activities and other activities). However, even when a single building is indicated under Section RB, because of the way the cadastral system is structured it is not possible to obtain a breakdown based on commercial/non-commercial uses of a building and therefore it is not possible to identify what portion of the building was used for the economic activity that generated the revenue stated in the tax declaration.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 15 September 2016. Pietro Ferracci v European Commission.Decision

    As regards, moreover, the tax databases, the Commission stated in recital 196 of the contested decision that they, too, did not provide sufficient information for recovery purposes.

    15 Sep 2016 · 62013TJ0219