192 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.5. Recovery › 6.5.2. Exceptional circumstances: absolute impossibility of recovery, Decision_act (EU) 2013/284

In forcesince 19 Dec 2012cited 1×

Member States usually raise this argument in the context of the discussions with the Commission after the adoption of the decision [Case C-214/07 Commission v Spain [2008] ECR I-8357, paragraphs 13 and 22.]. However, in this case, Italy already argued before the adoption of the decision that recovery should not be ordered because it would be absolutely impossible to implement it. Since Italy raised this issue in the context of the formal investigation, and since a general principle of law states that no one can be obliged to do the impossible, the Commission considers that it is necessary to deal with this question in the present Decision.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 15 September 2016. Pietro Ferracci v European Commission.Decision

    In the contested decision, the Commission stated, in recitals 191 to 198, that, given the specific nature of the present case, it would be absolutely impossible for the Italian Republic to recover any aid illegally granted under the ICI …

    15 Sep 2016 · 62013TJ0219