189 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.5. Recovery › 6.5.1. Legitimate expectation, Decision_act (EU) 2013/284

In forcesince 19 Dec 2012

Italy has also argued that the replies given by the Commission to the complainants on the ICI exemption, about which Italy was informally told, created a legitimate expectation on the part of the non-commercial entities as regards the compatibility of the ICI exemption with Union law. The Commission does not agree with the views expressed by Italy. Preliminary assessment letters sent by the Commission to the complainants, of which the Member State was only unofficially informed, do not constitute the Commission’s final position. Whereas Commission decisions are made public and published in the Official Journal, this is not the case in a simple administrative procedure where - on the basis of the facts available - the Commission does not harbour serious doubts about the compatibility of the measures examined. Moreover, the letter sent to the complainants on 15 February 2010 was challenged by two complainants before the General Court and did not become final; these Court actions were withdrawn only subsequent to the decision initiating the procedure.