141 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.2. The ICI exemption › 6.2.6. Classification of the measure as new aid, Decision_act (EU) 2013/284

In forcesince 19 Dec 2012

The Commission does not consider the Italian authorities’ arguments to be correct. First, the Commission points out that ICI is completely different from the earlier property taxes that it replaces. In any case, there are a number of substantial differences between ICI and the previous real estate taxes, in terms of taxable persons, taxable base and events which gave rise to the obligation to pay these taxes. For instance, until the introduction of ICI, real estate taxes were calculated on the capital gain of the real estate whereas ICI was calculated on the basis of the real estate’s cadastral value. In addition, whereas INVIM was due by the transferor for consideration or by the transferee without charge, ICI was due by every natural and legal person that possessed real estate. Finally, whereas INVIM was generally paid every ten years, ICI had to be paid each year. In the light of the above, the Commission considers that the amendments introduced over time and, in particular, with the ICI Law, affect the actual substance of the original scheme and cannot be separated from it, so that the original scheme is transformed into a new aid scheme [Joined Cases T-195/01 and T-207/01 Government of Gibraltar v Commission [2002] ECR II-2309, paragraph 111.]. The Commission has no reason to review the position set out in the decision initiating the procedure and confirms that the ICI exemption constituted new aid.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 30 April 2002. Government of Gibraltar v Commission of theDecision

    30 Apr 2002 · 62001TJ0195