Third, the Commission notes also that, as already stated, a measure which creates an exception to the application of a general tax system may be justified if it results directly from the basic or guiding principles of the (reference) tax system, in this instance the ICI. In this context, as stated in paragraph 26 of the Commission notice on the application of the state aid rules to measures relating to direct business taxation [OJ C 384, 10.12.1998, p. 3.], a distinction must be made between, on the one hand, the external objectives assigned to a particular tax scheme (in particular, social or social objectives) and, on the other hand, the objectives which are inherent in the tax system itself. Consequently, tax exemptions which are the result of objectives unrelated to the reference tax system cannot circumvent the requirements under Article 107(1) of the Treaty [Joined Cases C-78/08 to C-80/08 Paint Graphos, paragraph 70.]. The primary purpose of the tax system in question is to collect revenue to finance state expenditure [See paragraph 26 of the Commission notice on the application of the state aid rules to measures relating to direct business taxation.] by taxing possession of real estate. Thus, the Commission considers that the social objectives pursued by the entities falling within the scope of the ICI exemption are external to the logic of the ICI tax system and therefore cannot be relied upon to justify prima facie the selectivity of the measure.
126 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.2. The ICI exemption › 6.2.3. Selectivity › c) Justification by the nature and general scheme of the tax system, Decision_act (EU) 2013/284
In forcesince 19 Dec 2012
Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 8 September 2011. Ministero dell’Economia e delle Finanze and Agenzia delle Entrate v Paint GraphosDecision
8 Sep 2011 · 62008CJ0078
- case:eu=C-80/80
- celex=31978D0008