19 A. PROCEDURE › 2. PARTIES CONCERNED BY THE PROCEEDING › 2.3. QUESTIONNAIRE REPLIES AND VERIFICATIONS, Decision_act (EU) 2012/343

In forcesince 27 Jun 2012

As concerns the first argument, Article 17(3) of the basic Regulation as well as Article 6.10 of the ADA explicitly allow the investigating authority not to consider requests for IE if the number of exporters and/or producers involved is so large as to make such a determination impracticable. The WTO Appellate Body Report in the Fasteners case clarified that timely requests for IE should ‘as a rule’ be accepted unless this would be ‘unduly burdensome’ [See aforementioned Report of the Appellate Body of 15 July 2011, recital 319.]. In this case, the verification of the questionnaire replies and the replies to the MET claim forms of the applicants for IE would entail on-the-spot investigations at one company (applicant A) and two other companies (those forming part of applicant B). During these on-the-spot investigations, compliance with the provisions of Article 2(7)(c) would need to be verified as well as all these entities’ reported structure, costs (including production costs and purchases), sales and profitability. In view of the large number of entities already investigated within the sample, to add an additional applicant would indeed have been unduly burdensome and would have seriously jeopardised the completion of the investigation in good time. Therefore, the decision not to accept these requests for individual examination is justified by the law and not in breach with the principle of proportionality.