155 E. CAUSATION › 3. EFFECTS OF OTHER FACTORS › (i) Contraction in Union demand, probably partly related to the financial and economic crisis of 2008/2009, Decision_act (EU) 2012/343

In forcesince 27 Jun 2012

In the Oxalic acid case [OJ L 275, 20.10.2011, p. 1.], although some indicators indeed marked a positive development between 2009 and the IP, the market share of the Union industry decreased, whereas in the present case it increased almost to the level of 2007 [Ibid, recital 75.]. Furthermore, the Oxalic acid case does not show a year-on-year absence of correlation between dumped imports from the countries concerned and the trends of the injury indicators, which is characteristic of the present case. The profitability trends are also different. Notably, in the present case the profitability fluctuates considerably. Finally, in the present case the market is highly volatile.