IV. OBSERVATIONS OF THE GREEK AUTHORITIES ON THE FORMAL OPENING OF THE PROCEDURE › (a) Observations of the Greek authorities on the opening of the first procedure, Decision_act (EU) 2012/307

In forcesince 19 Oct 2011
(57)

In their letter of 9 August 2004, the Greek authorities made the following statements:

(a)

the consolidation of the loans is an administrative instrument not resulting in high costs for the public authorities;

(b)

the calculation of interest per six-month period has already been upheld in the case-law of the national Supreme Court, which declared quarterly compounding to be illegal and abusive, and responsible for imposing an excessive burden on debtors;

(c)

the granting of the State guarantee cannot be considered as aid since its use is contingent on particularly stringent measures for the principal debtor;

(d)

during the reference period, interest rates in Greece were much higher than the average rates in the rest of the Union and remained thus despite the reductions; there was therefore no distortion of competition, not least since the beneficiary firms had to be viable; moreover, the reductions were financed by a special account, separate from the State budget;

(e)

the granting of periods of grace cannot be considered as an aid measure, given that the debt and interest remain: this merely constitutes restructuring of repayment over time, justified on the grounds of the economic situation;

(f)

Ministerial Decision No 72742/B1723 (cf. recital 42 above) did not give rise to any additional costs in relation to those introduced by the original Decision which constitutes the basis of the scheme in question;

(g)

the release of securities by means of Ministerial Decision No 2071670/11297 cannot be considered an aid measure in respect of firms, since they are adapted to the level of the restructured loans; moreover, the guarantee from the Greek State does not cover all types of charges imposed on lenders by the banks;

(h)

Ministerial Decision No 69836/B1451 and its amendments concerned processing firms in general and did not refer specifically to processing firms in the agriculture sector, which were covered by Council Regulations (EEC) No 866/90 of 29 March 1990 on improving the processing and marketing conditions for agricultural products [OJ L 91, 6.4.1990, p. 1.], (EC) No 951/97 of 20 May 1997 on improving the processing and marketing conditions for agricultural products [OJ L 142, 2.6.1997, p. 22.] and (EC) No 1257/1999 of 17 May 1999 on support for rural development from the European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund (EAGGF) [OJ L 160, 26.6.1999, p. 80.]; these Regulations were applied by means of the implementation of operational programmes under the second and third Community Support Frameworks; firms which had made investments and received aid from the Ministry of Rural Development and Food to this end were not eligible for debt restructuring, since this had not been provided for; the de minimis rule was not applied either since, in order to obtain a subsidy, operators had to have carried out work and borne the cost;

(i)

the reference to the de minimis rule served exclusively to illustrate the fact that most of the aid measures granted were below the de minimis ceiling, without specific reference to the agricultural sector;

(j)

the criterion of ‘viability after restructuring’ has no bearing on the overall assessment of the viability of the firm prepared by the credit body, since eligibility for restructuring is determined immediately after the viability study;

(k)

the restructuring concerned old loans and did not constitute financing for new investments;

(l)

as regards the overall grant equivalent for the restructuring, the vast majority of the aid measures constituted small amounts, the areas for which the measures were intended (Kastoria and Evia) were all less-favoured areas within the meaning of Council Directive 75/268/EEC of 28 April 1975 on mountain and hill farming in certain less-favoured areas [OJ L 128, 19.5.1975, p. 1.], and the country as a whole falls under Objective 1;

(m)

the interest rate applied to new loans was that which applied to the latest issue of Greek Treasury bonds; the reduction does not concern the entire duration of the restructured loan, but only the first critical years; the difference between the rates was not very high (1 to 2 points);

(n)

the scheme existed from 30 June 1993 to 30 June 2003.

  • celex=31975L0268
  • celex=31990R0866
  • celex=31997R0951
  • celex=31999R1257
  • num:eu=1975/268