Decisions on questions of substance adopted by the Commission shall become binding on the members of the Commission in the following manner:
the Executive Secretary shall promptly notify each decision to all members of the Commission; and
subject to paragraph 2, the decision shall become binding upon all members of the Commission 90 days after the date of transmittal specified in the notification pursuant to subparagraph (a) ‘the date of notification’.
a) Any member of the Commission may present to the Executive Secretary an objection to a decision within 60 days of the date of notification ‘the objection period’. In that event the decision shall not become binding on that member of the Commission to the extent of the objection, except in accordance with paragraph 3 and Annex II.
A member of the Commission that presents an objection shall at the same time:
specify in detail the grounds for its objection;
adopt alternative measures that are equivalent in effect to the decision to which it has objected and have the same date of application; and
iii) advise the Executive Secretary of the terms of such alternative measures.
The only admissible grounds for an objection are that the decision unjustifiably discriminates in form or in fact against the member of the Commission, or is inconsistent with the provisions of this Convention or other relevant international law as reflected in the 1982 Convention or the 1995 Agreement.
Any member of the Commission that has objected to a decision may at any time withdraw that objection. The decision shall then become binding on that member in accordance with paragraph 1(b) or on the date of the withdrawal of the objection whichever is the later.
The Executive Secretary shall promptly notify all members of the Commission of:
the receipt and withdrawal of each objection; and
the grounds for that objection and the alternative measures adopted, or proposed to be adopted, pursuant to paragraph 2.
a) When an objection is presented by a member of the Commission pursuant to paragraph 2, a Review Panel shall be established within 30 days after the end of the objection period. The Review Panel shall be established in accordance with the procedures in Annex II.
The Executive Secretary shall promptly notify all members of the Commission of the establishment of the Review Panel.
If two or more members of the Commission present objections based on the same grounds, those objections shall be dealt with by the same Review Panel, which shall have the membership specified in Annex II paragraph 2.
If two or more members of the Commission present objections on different grounds, those objections may, with the consent of the members of the Commission concerned, be dealt with by the same Review Panel, which shall have the membership specified in Annex II paragraph 2. In the absence of such consent, objections on different grounds shall be dealt with by separate Review Panels.
Within 45 days after its establishment, the Review Panel shall transmit to the Executive Secretary its findings and recommendations on whether the grounds specified for the objection presented by the member or members of the Commission are justified and whether the alternative measures adopted are equivalent in effect to the decision to which objection has been presented.
The Executive Secretary shall promptly notify all members of the Commission of the findings and recommendations of the Review Panel. The findings and recommendations of the Review Panel shall be dealt with and have effect as set out in Annex II.
Nothing in this Article limits the right of a member of the Commission at any time to refer a dispute concerning the interpretation or application of this Convention for binding settlement in accordance with the provisions of this Convention relating to the settlement of disputes.