Taking into account:
document 8241/05 ENFOPOL 40 concerning dynamic risk assessment in the context of international football matches;
document 8243/05 ENFOPOL 41 concerning police tactical performance for public order management in connection with international football matches;
the experience and lessons of Euro 2004 and subsequent tournaments;
evaluation of the policing philosophy, commonly known as the 3D approach (dialogue, de-escalation and determination) during Euro 2008;
the following considerations should be applied to the assessment of risk to safety and security before, during and after the event.
Current understanding of effective crowd management highlights the importance of:
maintaining perceptions of appropriate policing among crowd participants;
avoiding the use of force against crowds as a whole when only a minority are posing a risk to public order;
a ‘low profile’ or ‘graded’ tactical approach to policing that enhances police capability for communication, dialogue and dynamic risk assessment.
the strategic approach should be preventative through low-impact intervention rather than repressive;
it is important that at every stage of an operation police strategy and tactics should take account of and facilitate the legitimate intentions of supporters, as far as these are peaceful (e.g. to celebrate their identity and culture, travel to and from the fixture in safety);
if it is necessary to impose limits on supporter behaviour, it is important to communicate with those supporters why police action has been taken and what alternative means the police are putting in place through which legitimate aims can be achieved.
during any crowd event the levels of risk to public order can change rapidly;
it is important that there is a proportionate balance between the style of police deployment and the level, sources and nature of risk at the point of police crowd interaction;
it is important that the policing is graded and capable of changing directly in response to the nature and levels of emerging and decreasing risk;
where balance is achieved the majority in the crowd are more likely to perceive the actions of the police as appropriate and less likely to support and associate with those seeking confrontation;
therefore, to help decrease the likelihood and scale of incidents, it is critical that risk assessments are accurate and inform police tactics at all times.
the indiscriminate use of force can contribute to a widespread escalation in the levels of public disorder through its interaction with crowd dynamics;
differentiation between individual supporters actually posing a danger and those that do not is therefore a consideration that must be built into every strategic and tactical decision relating to the management of crowds (i.e. training, planning, briefing and operational practice);
it is inappropriate to act against a whole crowd who happen to be present in a given location, unless there is evidence that they are uniformly seeking to provoke disorder.
it is important to communicate proactively with supporters. This is best achieved by police officers with good communication skills;
the focus is to create a welcoming atmosphere and avoid the potential for conflict;
this approach can assist in the gathering of high quality information regarding supporter intentions, perspectives, concerns and sensitivities and any other information regarding potential risk;
it also allows the police to communicate concerns regarding supporter behaviour, risks they may face and solutions to any emerging difficulties.
Risk assessment should take into account:
the underlying culture of the supporter group to be policed (e.g. characteristic behaviour, motivations and intentions);
any factors likely to impact on risk e.g. the activities of other groups (such as opposition supporters and / or local communities), sensitivities, history, and anything else that has particular significance (dates, places, forms of action, symbols);
any circumstances likely to impact on the behaviour of, or risk posed by, those supporters or groups perceived to pose a risk to public order.
Behavioural tolerance levels should be defined and priority given to communicating these to supporter organisations. Consideration should be given to encouraging supporters to gather in a safe/controlled environment (e.g. a fan zone).
Based upon this information and intelligence relating to the specific fixture it should be possible to predict and distinguish fixtures with normal risk and increased risk to public order.
It is important to clearly distinguish between risks for specific types of incidents, such as public order, public safety, criminality in relation to mass events and terrorism.
Since the level of risk to public order is not fixed but highly dynamic it can increase and decrease rapidly in response to circumstances. The levels of risk must therefore be monitored and accurately assessed on an ongoing basis.
To achieve this:
police should engage in high levels of positive interpersonal interaction with supporters (non-aggressive posture, smiling, deployed in pairs or in small groups in standard uniform, dispersed widely across and within crowds, accommodating requests for photographs, etc);
where language is not a barrier, officers should try to communicate with supporters to gather information about their demeanour, intentions, concerns, sensibilities and any other issues relevant to their behaviour;
interventions units (i.e. ‘riot squads’ with protective equipment, vehicles, etc) should be kept in discreet locations unless the situation determines that a more forceful intervention is required.
This will assist the organising police gather information and inform command decisions regarding tactical deployment on the basis of continuous and ongoing risk assessment.
Where circumstances posing risk are identified it is important to:
communicate to those posing the risk that they are provoking the potential for police intervention;
where an incident involves visiting supporters organising police assessments should be validated by the visiting police delegation.
Should the above measures not resolve the situation, then further police use of force may be required. The objective of police deployment at this stage is to minimise further risk and it is therefore essential that any action does not escalate tensions (e.g. indiscriminate use of force). Where any potential for an increase in risk is identified:
it is vital that information about the persons creating the risk and its nature is communicated clearly to the intervention squads being deployed so that any use of force can be appropriately targeted;
those not posing any risk should be allowed to leave the vicinity and / or some time to impose ‘self-policing’.
once the incident(s) has been resolved policing levels should return to an appropriate level.
a through debrief should be conducted and any relevant information (e.g. the quality of information received before and during the event, the behaviour and management of supporters, police tactics and the enforcement of tolerance levels) must be recorded with the NFIP.