137 7. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURES › 7.4. Compatibility of the aid: derogation under Article 87(3) of the EC Treaty › 7.4.4. Avoidance of undue distortion of competition › Compensatory measures under the November plan, Decision_act (EU) 2010/174

In forcesince 10 Mar 2009

The 2004 Guidelines recognise that different forms of aid can have different effects on competition. Furthermore, in order to limit the distortive effect, point 45 stipulates that the amount of the aid or the form in which it is granted must be such as to avoid providing the company with surplus cash which could be used for aggressive, market-distorting activities not linked to the restructuring process. The Commission doubted whether the compensatory measures under the November plan were sufficient. The Polish authorities admit that the effect of swapping HSW’s debt for equity is advantageous for HSW, as it significantly improves the company’s cash-flow situation. HSW is better off thanks to this change in the form of State aid. Moreover, HSW plans to use a major part of the free cash-flow to offer its customers competitive conditions. The Commission therefore considers that the compensatory measures implemented under the February plan would, on their own, be insufficient, as the swap has an additional distorting effect on competition. As a result, the compensatory measures had to be increased, as they have to be in proportion to the distorting effects of the aid [See point 40 of the 2004 Guidelines.].