13 III. ASSESSMENT › Savings, Decision_act (EU) 2010/12

In forcesince 5 Jan 2010

As mentioned under recital 5 above, the Italian competition authority has dealt with various mergers [See in particular the authority’s ruling of 20 December 2007, No 16249, C8027 Intesa/Sanpaolo, in Bull. 49/2006.] between banks or other financial institutions in Italy and found the financial services provided by Poste in connection with its postal accounts to be ‘complementary’ to rather than ‘substitutable’ for the services provided by banks through the various forms of bank accounts. This practice must, however, be seen in its context, namely, an examination of Poste’s possibilities of bringing competitive pressure to bear on banks [In fact, the detailed analysis carried out in the abovementioned Intesa/Sanpaolo case, looked, inter alia, at the degree to which bank customers would be inclined to change to the services provided by Poste.]. The detailed analysis carried out by or for the Italian competition authority shows that a large majority of customers [78,1 % would not consider changing to a postal account as opposed to 10,1 % who would. Globally, the same tendency was also found when examining the willingness of bank customers to change when faced with 5 % rises in charges related to the use of a bank account. Here also, a majority was not willing to abandon their bank account in favour of a postal account.] having a bank account would not consider closing that account and opening a postal account. Thus, in 2005, over 28 million (legal or natural) persons had a bank account only, over 3 million had both a bank account and a postal account and less than 2,3 million persons had only a postal account. It is also noteworthy that the number of persons having a postal account only was found to grow less than the number of persons having both a postal account and a bank account. These facts may to a large extent be explained through the normative restraints under which Poste operates and the ensuing fact that it offers a more restricted range of services connected to its accounts. Customers whose needs include a broad range of services would therefore be reticent to consider changing to a postal account not offering the accustomed range of services [While the normative restraints will remain unchanged, Poste has started broadening the range of services it offers, which should intensify competition.]. The reason most frequently given for having both types of accounts was the ‘possibility to choose from time to time the most practical/easy and or the most advantageous/economic [means]’.