9 C. COMMENTS OF PARTIES AND ACCEPTANCE OF THE UNDERTAKING, Decision_act (EU) 2009/736

In force

The Community industry indicated that the undertaking from Brazil could be acceptable under certain conditions, including the use of an artificial exchange rate from the USD to the EUR and a quantitative ceiling. Both of these arguments regarding the Brazilian undertaking have to be rejected on the following grounds. In respect of the claim that an artificial exchange rate should be used, it is noted that the LME price will be converted from USD into EUR using the published monthly exchange rate and therefore the amount in EUR is affected by exchange rate fluctuations, which is at the company’s own risk. With regard to the second argument, the Commission does not see the relevance of a quantitative ceiling in this case, given the very competitive market for the product concerned in the European Community and given that no evidence was submitted or found during the investigation showing the necessity of such an element. No other comments were submitted in respect to this undertaking offer.