10 III. ASSESSMENT › Services to which Article 30(1) of Directive 2004/17/EC is not applicable › Addressed first class letter services, Decision_act (EU) 2009/46

In forcesince 19 Dec 2008

In respect of addressed first class letters, Sweden Post has a market share which has been stable at slightly more than [… %] [Confidential information.] each year between 2005 and 2007, whether measured in terms of value or of volume [Measured by value, the markets shares were [… %] for, respectively, 2005, 2006 and 2007, whereas the corresponding markets shares measured in terms of volume for the same years were respectively [… %].]. According to Sweden Post, this level of market share would not differ to any significant degree even if referred separately to each of the possible segments that could be contemplated (CtC, CtB, BtC, BtB, domestic and international, letters and first class newspapers, single items and shipments, sorted and unsorted shipments, large and small shipments, metropolitan area and the rest of Sweden (…)) [See the request, point 3.1, C, p. 25-26.]. Consequently, in the present case, the question whether or not all these segments are part of the same product market can be left open. However, according to Sweden Post, the relevant market to evaluate its markets position against, would be a larger ‘Messages Market’, which, in addition to addressed letters of all categories and types, priority and non-priority newspapers and periodicals as well as addressed direct mail, would include ‘all electronic alternatives to physical distribution of postal items. (…) Examples include e-mail, EDI, communication via websites (with information submission, transaction execution, etc.), business systems (which generate communication and service applications, such as e-invoicing systems) and telephony services (in the form of SMS and MMS).’ On a market thus defined Sweden Post would have ‘a limited market share’. According to Sweden Post there would, in fact, be competitive pressure from the possibility to substitute ‘traditional’ paper-based letter services with electronic means of communication (such as e-mail or SMS). In respect of substitution, it should be noted that according to EC competition rules, substitutability should be analysed inter alia on the basis of product characteristics, price of the products and barriers associated with the switching of demand to potential substitutes. It appears that the characteristics of paper-based mail and of electronic communications differ significantly in terms of the form of communication, the consumption of time of the communication and the customer preferences. There are also significant barriers to switching between paper-based mail and electronic mail [For instance, roughly one quarter of Swedish households are not connected to the Internet. Furthermore, the part of the Swedish population that pays its bills via internet is stated to be ‘slightly over half’, which, conversely, means that almost half do not do so.]. This indicates that electronic communications belong to a different product market and therefore they cannot exercise a direct competitive restraint on Sweden Post’s addressed first class letter services. Furthermore, it would seem that the main effect of the increased use of electronic mail would substantially reduce the overall size of the paper-based mail market, rather than introduce competition within it [See also the conclusion in the same sense set out in recital 10 of Commission Decision 2007/564/EC of 6 August 2007 exempting certain services in the postal sector in Finland, excluding the Åland Islands, from the application of Directive 2004/17/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council coordinating the procurement procedures of entities operating in the water, energy, transport and postal services sectors (OJ L 215, 18.8.2007, p. 21).]. Whether there is direct exposure to competition can therefore not be evaluated using the ‘messages market’ as reference. Failing that, Sweden Post argues that the relevant market would be a ‘market for addressed physical messages’, that is one single market covering all forms and categories of letters (priority and non-priority, express and ‘normal’), addressed direct mail, newspapers and periodicals. On the thus defined market, the market share of Sweden Post for 2007 is stated to be [… %] in terms of value and [… %] in terms of volume. Apart from the fact that pricing conditions are widely different for the different types of services concerned, this high market share spans over market shares for Sweden Post varying between [… %] and [… %] in terms of value and between [… %] and [… %] in terms of volume, which is not consistent with one single market. The market for addressed first class letters should therefore be evaluated separately and the market shares of Sweden Post on that market are such that, in the absence of any indications to the contrary, it should be concluded that the services relating to addressed first class letters examined in this recital are not directly exposed to competition in Sweden. Therefore Article 30(1) of Directive 2004/17/EC does not apply to contracts intended to enable the pursuit of those activities in Sweden.