Some interested parties argued that the product concerned, as set out in recital 16 of the provisional Regulation, and the like product are not alike as stated in recital 18 of the provisional Regulation since they would not share the same physical and chemical characteristics and are not used for the same purposes. According to those interested parties, the statement in recital 18 of the provisional Regulation fails to address the arguments brought forward during the investigation and is in contradiction with the adjustment made by the Commission in the undercutting calculations for de-caking certain quantities of the product concerned after arrival in the EU. It is firstly noted that the investigation has shown that the product concerned and the like product are both used in the same basic applications, i.e. mainly for the household cleaning (auto dish-wash products, detergents, water softeners) and as additives in food and beverages, but also in the personal care/cosmetics area. The claim that the product concerned would in fact not be used by certain users in the detergents, food and beverages industry because of its smell and/or colour was not further substantiated by evidence. The investigation has shown that only in one niche application, i.e. the pharmaceutical area, only the European citric acid was indeed used because of the cost of the special compliance test which is required. Since the pharmaceutical area represents only a small portion of the users’ total business, running the compliance test was not considered as economically justifiable business decision. Secondly, there is no contradiction between the adjustment made in the undercutting calculation for de-caking parts of the product concerned after importation, as mentioned in recital 64 of the provisional Regulation, and the statement that both products are alike as it is sufficient that the product concerned and the like product share the same basic chemical, physical and technical characteristics and have the same basic uses, which is the case. It is further noted that the caking as such does not happen because of specific characteristics of the Chinese product, but happens because every citric acid, regardless of its origin, due to its chemical composition shows a tendency to cake when being exposed to humidity and changes of temperature. As naturally only the product concerned is exposed over a longer period of time to humidity and changes of temperature during the shipping time to the EU, the problem mainly occurs for the product concerned, but not exclusively. Therefore, the adjustment simply takes account of the fact that the de-caking incurs additional costs mainly for the product concerned as the quantities that are affected by the caking either are de-caked (by breaking and sieving or liquefying the caked product) before further selling or are sold with a rebate. Thus, this claim should be rejected.
9 C. INITIATION OF THE CASE, PRODUCT CONCERNED AND LIKE PRODUCT, Council Regulation (EC) No 1193/2008 of 1 December 2008 imposing a definitive anti-dumpi…
In force