18 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Market economy treatment (MET), Council Regulation (EC) No 1187/2008 of 27 November 2008 imposing a definitive anti-dump…

In forcesince 27 Nov 2008

It should firstly be noted that the findings relating to the negative working capital were subsidiary findings and were not the main ones leading to the conclusion that the applicant did not fulfil the MET criterion. Secondly, a negative working capital alone can be a sign of managerial efficiency but only in a business with low inventory and low accounts receivable, which basically can only be found in enterprises operating on an almost cash-only basis, such as department stores and supermarkets. The analysis of the situation of this Chinese exporting producer, however, was completely different. A negative working capital has to be considered rather as a sign that a company may be facing bankruptcy or serious financial trouble. Under such circumstances, being able to receive huge amounts of ‘trade credits’ without any financial cost would be highly unlikely in market economy conditions. Therefore, the significant interest-free borrowings of the company which represented a significant share of its total short term liabilities (the latter representing 80 % of total liabilities) and which resulted to a significant level of negative working capital has to be considered as not in line with market economy behaviour.