Recital 12, Commission Regulation (EC) No 746/2008 of 17 June 2008 amending Annex VII to Regulation…

In forcesince 17 Jun 2008cited 2×

It appears from EFSA’s clarifications that the biodiversity of the disease agents in ovine and caprine animals is an important element which does not make it possible to exclude transmissibility to humans and that that diversity increases the likelihood of one of the TSE agents being transmissible. However, EFSA acknowledges that there is no scientific evidence of any direct link between TSE in ovine and caprine animals, other than BSE, and TSE in humans. The EFSA viewpoint that transmissibility to humans of TSE agents in ovine or caprine animals cannot be excluded is based on experimental studies on human species barrier and animal models (primates and mice). Those models, however, do not take into account genetic characteristics of humans which have a major influence on relative susceptibility to prion diseases. They also have limitations when extrapolating results to natural conditions, in particular regarding how well they represent the human species barrier and the uncertainty of how well the experimental inoculation route employed represents exposure under natural conditions. On that basis, it may be considered that although a risk of transmissibility to humans of TSE agents in ovine or caprine animals cannot be excluded, that risk would be extremely low, taking into account the fact that the evidence of transmissibility is based on experimental models which do not represent the natural conditions related to the real human species barrier and the real routes of infection.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Third Chamber, extended composition) of 9 September 2011. French Republic v European Commission.Decision

    Moreover, although, in its Statement on the Potential Human Health Risk from Changes to Classical Scrapie Controls of February 2008, SEAC confirmed that a link between classical scrapie and human TSEs could not be ruled out, it …

    9 Sep 2011 · 62007TJ0257

  • Order of the President of the Court of First Instance of 30 October 2008. French Republic v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    30 Oct 2008 · 62007TO0257(01)