Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003 foresees additional assistance for the preparation of dossiers, where necessary, for each category of additives or for other particular aims according to Article 7(5) of Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003.
Technological additives
Sensory additives
Nutritional additives
Zootechnical additives
Coccidiostats and histomonostats
Extrapolation from major to minor species
Pets and other non food-producing animals
Additives already authorised for use in food
Modification of authorisations
Renewal of authorisations
Re-evaluation of certain additives already authorised under Directive 70/524/EEC.
Any applications may be submitted following more than one of the specific requirements listed above.
Reasons shall be given for the omission from the dossier of any data prescribed in these sections.
The whole of the Section I of Annex II applies.
The Section II of Annex II applies as following:
for additives not subject to a specific holder of the authorisation the paragraphs 2.1.2, 2.1.3, 2.1.4, 2.1.4.2, 2.2, 2.3.1, 2.3.2, 2.4.1, 2.4.2, 2.4.4, 2.5, 2.6 apply;
for other additives subject to a specific holder of the authorisation, the whole of Section II applies.
Subsections 3.1, 3.2 and 3.4 of Annex II do not apply to silage additives where it can be demonstrated that:
no detectable amounts of the active substance(s) or relevant metabolites or the active agent(s) survive in the final feed; or
the active substance(s) and agent(s) occur as normal constituents of silage and use of the additive does not substantially increase their concentration compared to silage prepared without use of the additive (i.e. where there is no substantial change in exposure).
In the other cases the whole of Section 3 of Annex II applies.
For xenobiotic [A xenobiotic is a chemical substance which is not a natural component of the organism exposed to it. It can also cover substances which are present in much higher concentrations than are usual.] substances: the full subsection 3.1 of Annex II applies.
For silage additives:
the product shall be added to a basal diet and results compared to a negative control with the same diet. The basal diet may contain a single source of silage prepared without the use of an additive.
the dose selected for the tolerance studies shall be a multiple of the concentration present in the ensiled material at the time of normal use where this can be conclusively established. Particular consideration shall be given to product containing viable micro-organisms and their capacity for survival and multiplication during ensiling.
Tolerance studies can usually be limited to a ruminant species, normally the dairy cows. Studies involving other species are required only when the nature of the ensiled material makes it more appropriate for use with non-ruminants.
Other substances:
for the other substances requesting authorisation as technological additives not already authorised for feed use the absence of harm to animals at the highest proposed level shall be demonstrated. This demonstration may be limited to one experiment in one of the most sensitive target species or in one laboratory animal species.
The whole of subsection 3.1.2 of Annex II applies.
1.3.2.1. Metabolic and residue studies
Metabolic and residue studies are not required if:
the substance or its metabolites are not present in the feedingstuff at time of feeding; or
the substance excreted unchanged, or its metabolites can be demonstrated to be essentially not absorbed; or
the substance is absorbed in the form of physiological compounds; or
the active component(s) of the additive consists only of micro-organisms or enzymes).
Metabolic studies also are not required if the substance is naturally present in significant amounts in food or feedingstuffs or the substance is a normal constituent of body fluids or tissues. However, in these cases, there is a requirement for residue studies which can be limited to the comparison of the tissues/products levels in an untreated group and in the group supplemented with the highest recommended dose.
1.3.2.2. Toxicological studies
Toxicological studies are not required if:
the substance or its metabolites are not present in the feedingstuff at time of feeding; or
the substance is absorbed in the form of physiological compound(s); or
the product consists of micro-organisms commonly encountered in ensiled materials or those already used in food; or
the product consists of enzymes with a high degree of purity arising from micro-organisms with a history of documented safe use.
For micro-organisms and enzymes not excluded above, genotoxicity studies (including mutagenicity) and a subchronic oral toxicity study are required. Genotoxicity studies shall not be made in the presence of living cells.
For xenobiotic substances, not exempted above, the whole of subsection 3.2.2 Annex II applies.
For other substances a case by case approach shall be taken, taking into account the level and means of exposure.
1.3.2.3. Assessment of consumer safety
The whole of subsection 3.2.3 of Annex II applies for additives requested for food producing animals.
The whole of subsection 3.3 of Annex II applies. Additives containing enzymes and micro-organisms are assumed to be respiratory sensitisers unless convincing evidence to the contrary is provided.
The whole of subsection 3.4 of Annex II applies. For silage additives, the effects of the additive on the production of effluent from clamp or silo during ensiling shall be considered.
Technological additives are intended to improve or stabilise the characteristics of feed but have generally no direct biological effect on animal production. Evidence of the efficacy of the additive must be provided by means of appropriate criteria as reflected in recognised acceptable methods, under the intended practical conditions of use in comparison with appropriate control feed.
Efficacy will be assessed by in vitro studies, with the exception of substances for control of radionuclide contamination. The appropriate end-points are indicated in the following table for the various functional groups.
Functional group | End-points for demonstration of efficacy
Preservatives
Inhibition of microbial growth, particularly that of biotic and spoilage organisms. The period for which a preserving effect is claimed shall be demonstrated.
Antioxidants
Protection against oxidative damage of key nutrients/components during feedingstuff processing and/or storage. The period for which a protecting effect is claimed shall be demonstrated.
Emulsifiers
Formation/maintenance of stable emulsions of otherwise immiscible or poorly miscible feed ingredients.
Stabilisers
Maintenance of the physico-chemical state of feedingstuffs.
Thickeners
Viscosity of the feed materials or feedingstuffs.
Gelling agents
Formation of a gel resulting in a change in the texture of the feedingstuff.
Binders
Pellet durability or performance of pellet formation.
Substances for control of radionuclides
Evidence of reduced contamination of food of animal origin.
Anti-caking agents
Flow ability. The period for which an anti-caking effect is claimed shall be demonstrated.
Acidity regulators
pH and/or buffering capacity in feedingstuffs.
Silage additives
Improved production of silage;
Inhibition of undesirable micro-organisms;
Reduction of effluents;
Improved aerobic stability.
Denaturants
Indelible identification of feed materials.
Silage additives
Separate tests shall be made to demonstrate the effect requested on ensiling process [For purpose of this Regulation, ‘ensiling process’ means process by which natural deterioration of organic matter is controlled by acidification in anaerobic condition resulting from natural fermentation or/and addition of silage additives.]. The trials shall be performed with one example of each of the following categories (where all or unspecified forages are involved):
easy to ensile forage: > 3 % soluble carbohydrates in fresh material (e.g. whole plant maize, ryegrass, brome grass or sugar beet pulp),
moderately difficult to ensile forage: 1,5—3,0 % soluble carbohydrates in the fresh material (e.g. meadow grass, fescue or wilted alfalfa);
difficult to ensile forage: < 1,5 % soluble carbohydrates in the fresh material (e.g., orchard grass or leguminous plants).
Where requests are restricted to sub-categories of forage described in terms of dry matter (DM), the dry matter range shall be explicitly stated. Three tests shall then be made with material representative of the range, where possible using examples of different botanical origin.
Specific tests are required for the particular feedingstuffs.
The duration of the study normally shall be 90 days or longer at a constant temperature (recommended range 15—25 oC). Use of a shorter duration must be justified.
As a rule measurements of the following parameters shall be provided in comparison to the negative control:
dry matter and calculated dry matter losses (corrected for volatiles),
pH- decrease,
concentration of volatile fatty acids (e.g. acetic, butyric and propionic acids) and lactic acid,
concentration of alcohols (ethanol),
concentration of ammonia (g/kg of total nitrogen), and
content of hydro-soluble carbohydrates.
In addition, other microbiological and chemical parameters shall be included as appropriate to substantiate the specific claim made (e.g. numbers of lactate assimilating yeasts, numbers of Clostridia, numbers of Listeria and biogenic amines).
An effect sought for effluent reduction will be judged against the total volume of effluent produced over the entire experimental period, taking into account the likely effect on the environment (e.g. ecotoxicity of the effluent or biological oxygen demand). Reduction of effluent production shall be demonstrated directly. The capacity of the silo shall be sufficient to allow effluent to be released with the application of pressure. The duration of the study shall normally be 50 days. If a different period is used, this shall be justified.
Improved aerobic stability shall be demonstrated in comparison with a negative control. Stability studies shall be of at least seven days duration after exposure to air and additive shall provide evidence of stability for at least two days longer than that shown by untreated control. It is recommended that the experiment is made at an ambient temperature of 20 oC and a rise in temperature of 3 oC or more above background taken as indicative of instability. Temperature measures may be replaced by measurement of CO2 production.
This section shall apply under provision of Article 7(3)(g) of Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003. That is, a post-market monitoring plan is required only for additives that are GMOs or are produced from GMOs.
The whole of Section I of Annex II applies.
The Section II of Annex II applies as following:
for additives not subject to a specific holder of the authorisation the paragraphs 2.1.2, 2.1.3, 2.1.4, 2.1.4.2, 2.2, 2.3.1, 2.3.2, 2.4.1, 2.4.2, 2.4.4, 2.5, 2.6 apply;
for other additives subject to a specific holder of the authorisation, the whole of Section II applies.
Subsection 3.3 of Annex II applies fully for every additive.
For substances which, when fed to animals, add colours to food of animal origin Section III subsections 3.1, 3.2 and 3.4 of Annex II apply in full.
For substances that add or restore colour in feedingstuffs, studies concerning Section III subsection 3.1 shall be performed on animals receiving the additive at the recommended dose. Evidence can also be provided by reference to existing scientific literature. Section III subsections 3.2 and 3.4 of Annex II apply.
For substances which favourably affect the colour of ornamental fish or birds, studies concerning Section III subsection 3.1 of Annex II are required and shall be performed on animals receiving the additive at the recommended dose. Evidence can also be provided by reference to existing scientific literature. However, subsections 3.2 and 3.4 are not required.
The whole of Section IV of Annex II applies.
For substances which, when fed to animals, add colour to food of animal origin:
changes of the colour of products obtained from animals receiving the additive at the recommended conditions of use shall be measured using the appropriate methodology. It shall be demonstrated that the use of the additive does not adversely affect product stability or organoleptic and nutritional qualities of the food. In principle, if effects of a particular substance on the composition/characteristics of animal products are well documented, then other studies (e.g. bioavailability studies) may provide adequate evidence of efficacy.
For substances that add or restore colour in feedingstuffs:
evidence of efficacy shall be provided by adequate laboratory studies reflecting the intended conditions of use in comparison with control feedingstuffs.
For substances which favourably affect the colour of ornamental fish and birds:
studies demonstrating the effect(s) shall be performed on animals receiving the additive at the recommended levels of use. Colour changes shall be measured using the appropriate methodology. Evidence of efficacy may also be provided by other experimental studies (e.g. bioavailability) or by reference to scientific literature.
This section shall apply under the provision of Article 7(3)(g) of Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003. That is, a post-market monitoring plan is required only for additives that are GMOs or are produced from GMOs.
The whole of Section I of Annex II applies.
In general, in the case of the group ‘natural products’, whole plants, animals and other organisms and parts of these or products thereof resulting from very limited processing such as crushing, grinding or drying (e.g. many herbs and spices), shall not be considered as falling under this functional group flavourings of the category sensory additives.
For the purposes of the evaluation of applications of these products, flavourings are classified as follows:
Natural products:
1.1. Natural products — botanically defined.
1.2. Natural products — non-plant origin.
Natural or corresponding synthetic chemically defined flavourings
Artificial substances.
The relevant group, to which the product object of the application belongs, shall be indicated. In case the product does not fit into any of the above groups, this shall be mentioned and justified.
2.2.2.1. Characterisation of active substance(s)/agent(s)
The whole of the subsection 2.2 of Annex II applies.
In addition:
For all groups of flavourings, the relevant identification number(s) (such as FLAVIS [Identification number for chemically defined flavouring substances used in FLAVIS, the EU Flavour Information System, the database used within the Commission Regulation (EC) No 1565/2000 of 18 July 2000 (OJ L 180, 19.7.2000 p. 8) laying down the measures necessary for the adoption of an evaluation programme in application of Regulation (EC) No 2232/96 of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 299, 23.11.1996, p. 1).], Council of Europe [CoE no.: Council of Europe number used for botanically defined flavouring products in the Council of Europe's Report no. 1 on ‘Natural sources of flavourings’, Volume I, Strasbourg, 2000 and its subsequent volumes.], JECFA, CAS [CAS Number (CAS No) Chemical Abstracts Service Registry Number, unique identifier for chemical substances widely used in chemical inventory listings.] or any other internationally accepted numbering system) used specifically for the identification of flavouring products in feed and food shall always be provided when available.
Natural products — botanically defined
The characterisation of the natural botanically defined products shall include the scientific name of the plant of origin, its botanical classification (family, genus, species, if appropriate subspecies and variety) and the common names and synonyms in as many European languages as possible or other language(s) (such as the one(s) of the place(s) of cultivation or origin) where available. The parts of the plant used (leaves, flowers, seeds, fruits, tubers, etc) and for lesser known plants the place of cultivation, identification criteria, and other relevant aspects of these plants shall be indicated. The major components of the extract shall be identified and quantified and its range or variability provided. Special attention shall be given to impurities as mentioned in subsection 2.1.4 of Annex II. The concentrations of substances of toxicological concern [For the purpose of this section of this Regulation, ‘substance of toxicological concern’ means a substance with a tolerable daily or weekly intake (TDI or TWI), an ADI, or with a restriction in its use, or an active principle as defined in Council Directive 88/388/EEC relating to flavourings for use in foodstuffs and to source materials for their production, or an undesirable substance.] for humans or animals which may occur in the plant from which the extract is produced shall also be reported.
The pharmacological or related properties of the plant of origin, its parts or of derived products thereof shall be fully investigated and reported.
Natural products — non plant origin
An equivalent approach to the above may be used.
Natural or corresponding synthetic chemically defined flavourings
Besides the general requirements of subsection 2.2.1.1 of Annex II, the origin of the flavouring shall be specified.
2.2.2.2. Method of production and manufacture
The whole of the subsection 2.3 of Annex II applies.
In the case of non chemically well defined natural products, usually complex mixtures of many compounds obtained by an extraction process, a detailed description of the extraction process shall be provided. It is recommended to use in the description the relevant terminology such as essential oil, absolute, tincture, extract and related terms [Defined in Appendix 4 of the Council of Europe's Report no. 1 on ‘Natural sources of flavourings’, Volume I, Strasbourg, 2000.] widely used for botanically defined flavouring products to describe the extraction process. The extraction solvents used shall be specified, the precautions taken to avoid residues of the solvents, and the levels of residues where these are of toxicological concern if their presence would be unavoidable. The terms used to characterise the extract may include a reference to the method of extraction.
2.2.2.3. Methods of analysis
For natural products (either botanically defined or non-plant origin) which do not contain substances of toxicological concern for humans or animals, the standard requirement for methods of analysis of subsection 2.6 of Annex II may be replaced by a simpler qualitative method of analysis fit for the purpose for major or characteristic components of the product.
For natural or corresponding synthetic chemically defined flavourings which are not substances of toxicological concern for humans or animals the standard requirement for methods of analysis of subsection 2.6. of Annex II may be replaced by a simpler qualitative method of analysis fit for the purpose.
The whole of subsection 2.6 of Annex II applies for all other flavourings, such as those natural extracts which contain substances of toxicological concern, natural or corresponding synthetic chemically defined flavourings which are substances of toxicological concern themselves and artificial flavourings.
For all flavourings, animal exposure and intake calculations both from natural exposure and following addition of the flavouring to feedingstuffs shall be provided.
For flavouring belonging to the group artificial substances, the whole of Section III of Annex II applies.
2.2.3.1. Studies concerning the safety of use of the additive for target animals
Natural products (either botanically defined or non–plant origin)
The safety of these products may be assessed on the basis of its major and characteristic components and also considering known substances of toxicological concern. If the major or characteristic components are not already authorised as chemically defined flavourings or as feed additives, then it has to be verified whether they are substances of toxicological concern for humans or animals, and its toxicological properties have to be provided in accordance with subsection 3.1 of Annex II.
Natural or corresponding synthetic chemically defined flavourings
If these substances are authorised flavourings for humans, the safety for target species may be assessed taking into account the comparison between the level of intake by the target species from feed proposed by the applicant with that by humans from food. Metabolism and toxicological data on which the assessment for human used was made shall be submitted.
In all other cases different from the case where both levels of intake are similar, such as where the level of intake by the target animal proposed be the applicant is substantially higher than that by human from food or where the substance is not authorised in food, the safety for the target animals may be assessed by taking into account the following data: the principle of threshold of toxicological concern [JECFA (FAO/WHO, 1996, Food additive series 35, IPCS, WHO Geneva) corresponding threshold for target animal should be adjusted to take into account of animal weight and feed intake.], available toxicological and metabolism data for related compounds, and chemical structural alert consideration (following by analogy of the Commission Regulation (EC) No 1565/2000 of 18 July 2000 laying down the measures necessary for the adoption of an evaluation program in application of Regulation (EC) No 2232/96 of the European Parliament and of the Council) [OJ L 180, 19.7.2000, p. 8.].
Tolerance studies are needed only where threshold values are exceeded or cannot be determined.
2.2.3.2. Studies concerning the safety of use of the additive for consumers
Evidence that the metabolites of the flavouring do not result in an accumulation in the animal of products of toxicological concern for humans shall be provided. In the case that the use of the requested flavouring product as a consequence of its addition to feedingstuffs results in residues in food of animal origin, detailed calculation of consumer exposure shall be provided.
Metabolic and residue studies
Natural products (either botanically defined or non–plant origin)
The safety of these products for humans when used as flavourings in feed, as regards its metabolism, may be based on the metabolism (in the target animal) and residues studies of their major and characteristic components and the absence of substances of toxicological concern in the extract.