Austria argued that the aid element would in any case be far from the nominal value of the guarantee. The capital market has hybrid equity instruments with clear features of liabilities, which the banking supervision regulations accept as Tier 1 capital. These instruments, due to banking supervision regulations, would have lengthy minimum terms, which as a rule are at least 10 years. Such instruments would be subject to a fixed rate of return, which is of course higher than the rate to be paid for a one-year instrument. Banks with a rating comparable to that of BAWAG-PSK issued hybrid capital in spring/summer 2006 with a ten-year minimum term and bearing interest rates of approximately 5,1 %:
Table 3
Overview of hybrid capital emissions from banks with comparable ratings
Issuer | Date of issue | Rating at the time of issuing | Interest rate
Banca Italease | 6 June 2006 |
Moody'sBaa2
FitchBBB+
CompositeBBB
5,159 %
AIB UK | 6 June 2006 |
Moody'sA2
S&PA–
FitchA+
CompositeA
5,142 %