77 V. COMMENTS FROM AUSTRIA › The aid element in the State guarantee, Decision_act (EU) 2008/263

In forcesince 27 Jun 2007

According to Austria, the fact that BAWAG-PSK was to be classified as a company in financial difficulties at the time the guarantee was granted does not mean that the aid element amounts to the nominal value of the guarantee of EUR 900 million. Instead, the Commission should exercise its discretion taking into account the specifics and the details of the Guarantee Agreement, especially the identified risk factor. According to this, the financial difficulties of a borrower would only be an indication for the existence of State aid; however, they would not enable any statement about the amount of the aid element involved. The Commission has in several restructuring cases determined the aid element in a guarantee granted in favour of a company in difficulty to be lower than the nominal value. In the case of Crédit Foncier de France [Commission Decision of 23 June 1999, C(1999) 2035, Crédit foncier de France (OJ L 34, 3.2.2001, p. 36), paragraph 49.] (hereafter CFF), the Commission calculated the amount of aid based on the market price the Bank would hypothetically have had to pay for such a guarantee on the market. In the case Bankgesellschaft Berlin [Commission Decision of 18 February 2004, C(2004) 327, Bankgesellschaft Berlin (OJ L 116, 4.5.2005, p. 1), paragraph 27, fourth indent.] (hereafter BGB), the Commission determined the amount of aid in a guarantee, the so-called risk shield, to be the ‘economic value’ rather than the nominal value. Also in the case of the restructuring aid granted by Germany to Chemische Werke Piesteritz [Commission Decision of 2 March 2005, C(2005) 427, Chemische Werke Piesteritz (OJ L 296, 12.11.2005, p. 19), paragraph 107.] (hereafter CWP), the Commission estimated the amount of aid in a guarantee far below the nominal value of the loan, although CWP was in financial difficulty at the time.