VII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID MEASURE › Aid amount › The sale scenarios, Decision_act (EU) 2008/263

In forcesince 27 Jun 2007
(149)

The value of BAWAG-PSK in April/May 2006, when the Law was adopted, can only be estimated through rough calculations:

(a)

using available documents, a private guarantor may have used a methodology based on discounted cash flows (DCF). However, such an approach, based on prospective figures over a reasonable timeframe, leads to figures where the terminal value represents a very high percentage of the total value. As an example, using the net profit indicated in the business plan submitted by Austria in September 2006 (as proxy for the information available to the private guarantor in April/May 2006), the DCF results in a value of EUR […] billion [Based on a 10 % discount rate.], with the terminal value equal to 85 % of the latter amount. Therefore, the Commission considers that the method does not allow for sound conclusions in the present case as it is too dependent on the terminal value;

(b)

using the purchase price of BAWAG-PSK, of EUR […] billion (which was not known in spring 2006), and the equity value as of 31 December 2005, of EUR 1,7 billion, a goodwill, representing the value of customers and branch network, can be computed. Its value is around EUR […] billion. Then, the sum of equity as of 31 December 2005 and of the goodwill, minus the capital injection to be made by the new owners of EUR […] million and the Refco payment of EUR […] million linked to the purchase price, lead to an estimated value of BAWAG-PSK in spring 2006 of around EUR […] billion [EUR 1,7 + EUR […] – EUR […] – EUR […] billion = EUR […] billion.].