The degree of concentration is also a good indicator of competition on the wholesale market for electricity as is the degree of liquidity. At the regional level, 42,82 % of electricity consumption in the Nordic countries was sold through Nord Pool Spot AS — the voluntary Nordic power exchange described in recital 9 — in 2004-2005 [Final Report, p. 126, paragraph 380, table 16.]. According to the Final Report, on that type of power exchange ‘the concentration in generation finds […] direct expression in a rather stable equivalent [Emphasis added for ease of reading.] concentration in the power exchanges’ [P. 141, paragraph 424.]. For the three largest generators in the Nordic area, this amounts to 40 % [P. 44, table 4,1, of the Technical Annex.], which, referred to a regional market, is at a satisfactory level. When referred to the sole Swedish market, the aggregate market shares of the three largest actors on the wholesale market are, of course, higher at 86 % [According to the information supplied by the Swedish authorities.] in 2006. It should, however, be stressed that there is competition between the three large and several smaller wholesale actors on the Swedish market. Furthermore, as regards the connection to the Nordic area, it should be noted again that the aforementioned bottleneck problems (congestion) are not constant, only temporary. There is therefore, in addition to domestic competition, a frequent external competitive pressure on the Swedish market deriving from the potential to obtain electricity from outside the Swedish territory. This is the more so as Sweden is the third biggest net importer of electricity in the EU in terms of percentage of its domestic consumption [Final Report, p. 112, paragraph 319.] and no transmission fee is charged between the Nordic countries. It should further be noted that the conditions of competition in wholesale trade in electricity are also greatly influenced by financial trade in electricity in the market area concerned, which, in terms of volume via Nord Pool, represented almost twice the amount consumed in the Nordic countries in 2005 [Final Report, p. 127, paragraph 383, table 17.] (and, if other identified transactions such as OTC — Over The Counter or direct sale — are included, more than five times the amount in 2005 [See the Final Report, p. 127, paragraph 383, table 17.]). In the Technical Annex [P. 44-45.], this degree of liquidity was considered as being satisfactory, i. e. it is such as to constitute an indicator of a well-functioning and competitive market. Given the strong link between the Swedish wholesale market and the Nordic market, this degree of liquidity should also be considered as providing a competitive pressure on the Swedish market. The Final Report also ranges Nord Pool among the ‘most liquid and efficient wholesale electricity markets’ [P. 193, paragraph 581.]. These factors should therefore be taken as an indication of direct exposure to competition for the wholesale market whether taken as the national Swedish market or the emerging regional one.
13 III. Assessment, Decision_act (EU) 2007/706
In force