7. COMMENTS FROM SWEDEN › 7.1. SVT's allegedly excessive transmission fee payments to Teracom, Decision_act (EU) 2007/258

In forcesince 20 Dec 2006
(79)

First, in the opening Decision, the Commission looks at Teracom's costs in the digital terrestrial network (column 3 of Table 2) excluding VAT although all other figures in the same table included VAT. According to the Government, all figures should exclude VAT to make them comparable [In particular, the Government has pointed out that the transmission fees which Teracom charges SVT include VAT and that the amounts which SVT receives from the distribution account allow for this. Teracom does not benefit from the part of the payment earmarked for VAT because it has to pay this money to the tax authority; see the 20 March response, question 2.]. Table 3 below presents the relevant table from the opening Decision corrected for VAT. According to these corrected figures, Teracom's accumulated profits will, by 2013, be significantly lower (SEK 23,7 million) than the amount indicated in the opening Decision (SEK 509,61 million).

Table 3:

SVT's transmission fee payments from SVT 2002 to 2013

(excluding VAT)

Source: The 29 October response, p. 25. Note, however, that the table still includes a number of errors which are explained and corrected in below.

Year |

Payments from SVT to Teracom

excl. VAT (1)

Teracom's costs of transmitting SVT in analogue

excl. VAT (2)

Teracom's costs of transmitting SVT in digital

(3)

Teracom's total costs of transmitting SVT

excl. VAT (4 = 2+3)

Teracom's predicted annual profits/losses

(5 = 4 — 1)

Teracom's predicted accumulated profits/losses

(6)

2002 | 388,0 | 384 | 160 | 544 | -156,0 | -156,0

2003 | 418,4 | 384 | 160 | 544 | -125,6 | -281,6

2004 | 445,2 | 384 | 160 | 544 | -98,8 | -380,4

2005 | 473,4 | 384 | 160 | 544 | -70,6 | -451,0

2006 | 205,0 | 192 | 160 | 352 | -147,1 | -598,1

2007 | 219,0 | 96 | 160 | 256 | -37,0 | -635,0

2008 | 233,3 | | 160 | 160 | 73,3 | -561,8

2009 | 247,7 | | 160 | 160 | 87,7 | -474,1

2010 | 262,2 | | 160 | 160 | 102,2 | -371,9

2011 | 276,9 | | 160 | 160 | 116,9 | -255,0

2012 | 291,8 | | 160 | 160 | 131,8 | -123,2

2013 | 306,8 | | 160 | 160 | 146,8 | 23,7