Both companies acknowledge that the basic cartel functions were developed through annual meetings throughout the 1990s. Indeed, company statements and documentary evidence has allowed the following cartel meetings to be identified:
annual meeting 22 November 1990, probably in Antony near Paris (see section 3.4)
annual meeting 1991
annual meeting September or October 1992
annual meeting(s) 5 October 1993, Paris, and/or 12 October 1993, Frankfurt
annual meeting about 19 October 1994, Frankfurt
annual meeting 4 October 1995, Frankfurt
introduction of [Merck employee 2] 2 July 1996, Novotel La Defense, Paris
annual meeting about 24 October 1996, Hotel Intercontinental, Frankfurt
annual meeting 6 October 1997, Novotel La Defense, Paris
annual meeting about 7 October 1998, Frankfurt
final meeting between 1 and 4 November 1999, Frankfurt.
3.7. Annual meeting, probably November or December 1991