The alleged investor contribution consisted of two soft loans granted by the State (measures 16 and 17) worth a total of DEM 2 million, and DEM 0,055 million which the investor brought into the company from his own resources by way of own capital. Only the latter contribution was fully private. The DEM 0,2 million loan under measure 16 was secured by a Federal Government guarantee. The DEM 1,8 million loan under measure 17 was secured by a mortgage on Kahla II's land. The purchase of these assets was financed by State aid. In view of the fact that these loans were granted out of State resources and bearing in mind the security provided, the loans under measures 16 and 17 clearly cannot be considered a contribution by a private investor. As for the alleged new interest payments amounting to DEM 0,986 million, the Commission has never received the slightest piece of information about this. Presumably they relate to the interest paid by Mr Raithel on the two loans under measures 16 and 17. However, these interest payments do not finance any restructuring costs. As regards cash flow, the Commission would point out that the forecast profit the company was to earn cannot be considered a substantial contribution within the meaning of the restructuring aid guidelines. What is more, the Commission has not been informed whether this cash flow was actually achieved or whether it was used to cover restructuring costs.
Recital 171, Decision_act (EU) 2003/643
In forcesince 13 May 2003