Recital 116, Decision_act (EU) 2003/643

In forcesince 13 May 2003

The Commission notes that table 11 is an ex post evaluation of the company's history. It is useful in that it confirms that the main forecasts of the reports available in 1994 were correct: losses were to be incurred during at least the first two years. However, the Commission must make its assessment from an ex ante point of view, that is, it must establish whether from 1994 Germany fulfilled its obligations under the EC Treaty and notified the aid. Had Germany fulfilled its obligations, the Commission would have based its assessment on the reports available at that time. As already stated in recitals 95, 96 and 113, those reports are based on the premiss that the company had to restore its viability and concluded that State support was absolutely essential to achieve that aim. In the light of those reports, the Commission would have followed its established practice and regarded Kahla II (an Auffanglösung) as a firm in difficulty. This conclusion cannot be altered, ex post, by the fact that, thanks to substantial aid awards, these difficulties were surmounted within a short space of time.