All these arguments must be dismissed. The fact that the results sought by the cartel participants were not entirely achieved does not prove in any way that the implementation of the cartel agreements had no effects in the market. In particular, the potential substitutability of other products for zinc phosphate is not demonstrated. SNCZ refers merely to the fact that one customer would have replaced zinc phosphate by calcium phosphate, but does not support this assertion by any concrete elements. SNCZ even acknowledges at the same time that though the use of calcium is developing, it is still "used in relatively small quantities"(185).
Recital 297, Decision_act (EU) 2003/437
In forcesince 11 Dec 2001