The Portuguese authorities also considered the initiation of the procedure to be excessive and unjustified in any event for two reasons in particular:
the Commission was obliged, at least from the entry into force of the Treaty of Amsterdam, to discriminate positively in favour of the outermost regions. In initiating the procedure laid down in Article 88(2), the Commission was failing to comply with that obligation, in particular because the Commission itself subsequently considered it necessary to amend the guidelines on regional aid(9) in order to take full account of the new Article 299(2),
the approach adopted in relation to the financial and tax aid scheme for the free zone of Madeira represented unequal treatment in comparison with other cases and/or regions. In this respect the Portuguese authorities considered in particular that the Irish International Financial Service Center had been allowed relatively flexible phasing out arrangements(10) while the Commission departments had rejected any possibility of compromise in relation to the free zone of Madeira.