Recital 67, Decision_act (EU) 2003/6

In forcesince 13 Dec 2000

In most cases, such as that of Vegla, the rebate system ensured that Solvay was secure in the position of exclusive supplier. The rebate system also operated however to ensure that where customers did have a policy of splitting their business between two suppliers the dominant share of Solvay was maintained. Flachglas, Solvay's second largest customer in Germany, divided its business roughly 70:30 between Solvay and M & W. From 1983 onwards, Solvay's pricing conditions to Flachglas involved an 8.5 % quantity rebate for tonnage up to 70000 tonnes, 20 % on any marginal tonnage, and a cheque for DEM 500000 to DEM 750000. The additional cheque rebate meant that the real price for any marginal tonnage taken over 70000 tonnes was (depending on the quantity) as low as DEM 250 or DEM 260 per tonne. It was extremely difficult for the second supplier to break into Solvay's "core" share of the business, which (as Solvay's own documents show) was protected by the rebate "barrier". While the second supplier might be able to match the invoiced price of DEM 322,40 (list price - 20 %) it was highly unlikely that the customer would risk losing the substantial cheque payment, which was clearly dependent upon its purchasing an appropriate tonnage from Solvay in addition to the basic contractual tonnage. Documentation obtained from Matthes & Weber confirms that it was impossible for that company to make any inroads into Solvay's share of the Flachglas business.