Regarding the question whether the Commission was provided with complete information prior to its decision of 13 March 1996, the Commission notes that the privatisation of the Lintra subsidiaries was in fact the subject of an investigation by the German Federal Court of Auditors which started in September 1995 and was concluded by a report on 16 September 1996. Following the initiation of the procedure, Germany submitted the complete correspondence between the BvS and the Court of Auditors as well as the final report. The correspondence between September 1995 and March 1996 shows that during this period the Court of Auditors only raised concerns about one of the contractual provisions, namely on the potential sharing of the BvS in future profits of the subsidiaries. A knowledge of the correspondence between the Court of Auditors and the BvS up until March 1996 would not have been a determining factor in the decision. The results of the final report were presented by the Court of Auditors only in September 1996, i.e. some six months after the decision of 13 March 1996, and could therefore not have been taken into account by the Commission at the time it was judging the compatibility of the aid.
Recital 24, Decision_act (EU) 2001/673
In force