Recital 76, Decision_act (EU) 2000/12

In forcesince 20 Jul 1999

The relevant markets as referred to in this Decision explicitly recognise the different characteristics of Pass France 98 vis-à-vis individual tickets. Nevertheless, the CFO's argument that blind sales of individual entry tickets by the CFO in 1997 are substitutable for sales by the CFO and other outlets at a later date is not accepted. The objective of defining relevant product markets is to identify the actual competitors of an undertaking that are capable of constraining the behaviour of that undertaking and of preventing it from behaving independently of effective competitive pressure. An analysis of the conditions under which sales took place of individual entry tickets relating to second-phase matches in 1997 by the CFO confirms that the CFO was able at that time to act in an environment free from any such competitive pressure. Those tickets related to prestigious matches for which the number of applications from consumers able to provide an address in France exceeded almost six times the available supply, notwithstanding the fact that the identities of participating teams were unknown at the time of sale(28). In view of such demand levels, and because consumers are unlikely in 1997 to have considered national football federations and European tour operators as realistic alternative sources of supply, the CFO was clearly able to operate, in relation to its sale of such tickets, as a de facto monopolist free from any competitive pressure from other undertakings.