, Report by the Court of Auditors on the operational efficiency of the management of the E…

In forcesince 6 May 1999
11.

The tendency, already noted in the past(6), of resorting to external consultants rather than recruiting specialist staff was more pronounced in 1997. The tasks to be carried out were not always entrusted to consultants because they required special technical knowledge or particular expertise, but mainly, under time pressure, in order to alleviate the lack of human resources and cope with the severe constraints imposed by the imminent launch of stage three.

12.

In the case of the FCRS(7) project, the consultant was given the responsibility of heading the project without being subject to any particular scrutiny by senior management and without any of the special control tools which this exceptional situation justified having been put in place.

13.

Increased recourse to consultants made coordinating, monitoring and controlling the projects more difficult. This resulted, particularly in the case of the FCRS project and, to a lesser degree, the ECB Accounting System project(8), in a poor definition of requirements, a delay in the planning of projects and inadequate control of expenditure.

14.

The Institute continued to use external interpreters on a regular basis (3,7 % of administrative costs other than staff costs) for a large number of meetings. Since its creation, these interpreters have always been placed at the Institute's disposal by the same agency without any tender procedure having ever been opened or any written contract concluded.

This report was adopted by the Court of Auditors in Luxembourg at its meeting of 6 May 1999.

For the Court of Auditors

In the absence of Jan O. KARLSSON

President of the Court

Bernhard FRIEDMANN

Acting President