Recital 137, Decision_act (EU) 1999/271

In force

Consequently, ETA should be described as the longa manus of Minoan, operating as a representative of Minoan, as an intermediary who acts exclusively on behalf of Minoan and does not undertake business on its own account. In all the documentary evidence used in this Decision, Mr Sfinias, the legal representative and manager of ETA, represented Minoan (Athens), signing all relevant documents, even a reply dated 20 November 1992 to a request for information addressed to Minoan by the Commission. Indeed, Mr Sfinias acted as the representative of a functional unit inside Minoan. All other companies replying to fax or telex messages signed by Mr Sfinias addressed their replies to "Minoan" or "Minoan Athens" and never to ETA. In all these documents, Mr Sfinias referred to ETA only when addressing Minoan headquarters in Heraklion, Crete. Nevertheless, Minoan refers to the documentary evidence used in this Decision, arguing that only 6 out of 17 Minoan documents relate to ETA's informing Minoan of the arrangements in question and that in only two of them does ETA request Minoan's approval of its suggestions. However, the Commission rejects the argument that the documents do not allow ETA's anti-competitive actions to be imputed to Minoan. It is clear from the Minoan documents emanating from its headquarters in Heraklion as well as from Mr Sfinias' messages to Minoan Heraklion that Minoan was aware of the collusion and participated in it (such as ETA documents dated 25 February 1992, 21 May 1992, 30 July 1992 where ETA acts as Minoan's representative vis à vis the other companies).