Recital 265, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

Where, as in the present case, an economic operator holds a dominant position in the market, exclusive supply (whether this is the object or the effect (101) of agreements concluded by this operator) constitutes an unacceptable obstacle to entry into the market and impairs the effective competitive structure envisaged by Article 3g of the Treaty (102). HB's freezer-cabinet agreements in outlets with only HB cabinets have the effect of eliminating the freedom of a very substantial number (103) (some 40 % of all outlets in the relevant market, which account for some 40 % of impulse ice cream sales in the relevant market, see paragraphs 156 and 184) of retailers to stock and offer for sale to the consumer ice cream of any competing suppliers. These retailers, as a result of the agreements, obtain all their requirements exclusively from HB. Consequently, access to the relevant market for other suppliers is made more difficult. The effect of a freezer-cabinet agreement subject to the condition of exclusivity is, in these circumstances, the same as that of any other measure taken by a dominant supplier which excludes its competitors from dealing with that retailer (104). Although the concept of abuse is an objective one, it may be noted that HB is not only aware of this exclusionary effect produced by its freezer-cabinet agreements but has indeed targeted it (see paragraph 64 et seq.).