Recital 251, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

HB is particularly critical of the fact that the Commission's assessment is based on the failure of only one element in those revised arrangements, the hire-purchase scheme. To this it should be responded that the hire-purchase scheme was not just one, but the central, element of the revised arrangements, and the key to the expected evolution towards wider retailer cabinet ownership. Its failure to attract retailers therefore inevitably entailed the failure of the desired effects to materialise. HB is also critical of the fact that the Commission appeared to have reached a premature conclusion about a measure which was only intended to produce effects over the longer term. In relation to this it can only be said that, by the time the Commission issued its Statement of Objections in January 1997, the scheme had already been running for two ice-cream seasons. Given that not a single retailer had by that stage opted to take a cabinet under the scheme, it was reasonable to assume that it was unlikely to have any long-term impact.