HB has also argued that its distribution arrangements lead to planning, logistic and distributive efficiencies; it contends that they facilitate the planning of deliveries and the rhythm of supply; the arrangements lead to efficiencies in distribution in that 'drop sizes` (the quantity taken by the retailer on one delivery) to freezer cabinets which only stock its products are greater than they would be in the absence of exclusivity, and that a high concentration of HB freezers also contributes to such efficiencies. As pointed out above (paragraph 224), the fact that the cabinet agreements may be advantageous to HB and even to the retailers is not sufficient to constitute an improvement in the distribution of goods within the meaning of Article 85(3); the agreements can only be considered as leading to such an improvement where the advantages can be demonstrated to be of an objective kind. Whilst it is clear that the current method of distribution operated by HB may produce certain advantages for itself and retailers in terms of efficiency, it should be pointed out that HB's exclusivity arrangements have the effect of undermining the efficiency of other impulse ice-cream suppliers by effectively requiring them to compete not only in the supply of ice cream but also in the provision of cabinets to retailers on attractive terms. The result is a strengthening of HB's position in the relevant market, reinforcing a barrier to entry into or expansion within it. As such, any advantages resulting from the agreements are clearly outweighed by the disadvantages which they bring in the form of restricted competition.
Recital 236, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531
In forcesince 11 Mar 1998