In relation to this argument, it must be stated that the reasons for the failure of the hire-purchase scheme introduced by HB in 1995 are not solely explicable by an unwillingness in principle on the part of retailers to own or lease their own cabinets. Rather, the Lansdowne survey found (see paragraph 100) that the principal reason was satisfaction with current arrangements, experience has shown that retailers, faced with the option of taking from HB a 'free on loan` cabinet or one on hire purchase, have invariably opted for the former. That it not to say that, in the absence of cabinet exclusivity, retailers would not continue to stock ice cream: the B& A survey found that over [. . .] % of retailers said that they would continue to do so in such hypothetical circumstances, and that many would choose to buy/lease their own cabinet to that end (see paragraph 120). In relation to HB's assertion that retailers will instead turn to HB's competitors for the provision of 'free on loan` supplier-exclusive freezer cabinets, it can only be said that if retailers do so to such an extent that that network, or those networks, of supplier-exclusive freezer cabinets (and where these are the only cabinets in place in those outlets) then contribute significantly to the overall foreclosure of the relevant market, then the relevant part of such network would equally fall foul of Article 85(1).
Recital 231, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531
In forcesince 11 Mar 1998