Recital 210, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

Again, the Commission cannot accept this reasoning. An agreement between any two parties is capable of producing an effect restrictive of competition within the meaning of Article 85(1), irrespective of the motivation of the parties in concluding such a restrictive agreement. More specifically, an exclusive purchasing arrangement of whatever kind is, in principle, liable to fall foul of Article 85(1) where it has the effect of foreclosing third party suppliers to a significant extent, notwithstanding the fact that the party subject to the exclusivity may express himself, at a given moment in time, to be disinterested in purchasing from any such third parties. As regards the apparently low level of consumer demand for brands other than HB, it should be pointed out that competitors' inability to gain access to wide-scale distribution for these impulse products is one of the principal reasons for absence of demand, particularly in the case of products which are being newly-launched (see paragraphs 12 and 44). In the absence of the exclusivity provision, retailers could more easily be persuaded to stock additional products, given that this would not in such circumstances require the replacement of an incumbent, or the installation of an additional, freezer cabinet. It can be expected that such additional brand stocking might in turn stimulate higher levels of consumer demand for brands other than HB.

8.

Property rights