Recital 208, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

HB considers that the Commission's reasoning is flawed in concluding that freezer-cabinet agreements which are 'effectively terminable at will` (in that HB apparently does not seek to enforce the two months' notice requirement) can lead to a de facto tie of the kind referred to at paragraph 184. A 'temporary relationship` of this kind is, according to HB, inconsistent with the existence of such a tie. The Commission does not agree. The cabinet agreements are of indefinite duration, requiring the initiative of either party to bring them to an end. Far from indicating that the contractual relationship is a temporary one, the evidence demonstrates that the opposite is true. The economic reality, as confirmed by the market research, is that retailers who take HB cabinets only very rarely replace them with their own or competitors' cabinets (see paragraph 158 et seq.). HB cabinet agreements are almost invariably replaced by identical cabinet agreements (see paragraph 111).