New entrants are, as a result of the barriers to entry described above, precluded in practice from many retail outlets for the sale of their products. When entry is possible, it can only be achieved at great cost, thereby presenting a particular obstacle to the entry of small and medium-sized companies. Existing suppliers are similarly restricted in their scope for expansion in the market. The relative numeric and weighted distribution figures achieved by the various ice-cream suppliers provides clear evidence of the difficulty in achieving wide distribution (see paragraphs 46 to 52): in particular, no supplier approaches the distribution levels being obtained by HB. Mars, for example, had achieved a higher degree of market penetration in the year after its entry (when retailers had been placing its products in HB cabinets) than it has managed to achieve in the more than five years which have elapsed since then (see paragraphs 47 and 48). Nestlé, who entered the market in 1994, has seen its numeric distribution level remain unchanged since then, and only a slight increase in the weighted level (see paragraph 50). The effectiveness of these barriers is understood by the suppliers operating the practice of cabinet provision subject to exclusivity. This is most clearly illustrated by the various reactions of HB to the market entry of Mars in 1989 (see paragraphs 64 to 68): it is evident from company documentation that HB's insistence on maintaining freezer exclusivity was not motivated by concern about 'piracy` of its property alone, but rather saw the exclusivity as a very useful means of checking the effective entry and expansion of the new rival.
Recital 196, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531
In forcesince 11 Mar 1998