Recital 162, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

The need to rupture relations with the supplier providing the cabinet to be replaced is a further impediment, particularly where that supplier enjoys a market position as strong as that held by HB. The very fact that there are so few retailers who have elected to purchase or lease freezer cabinets for the stocking of impulse ice cream in Ireland tends to confirm this analysis. Prior to HB's cabinet disposal in 1996, very few retailers in Ireland had opted to purchase their own cabinets (see Rosslyn survey at paragraph 107, carried out in April 1996, prior to the disposal). Most of the cabinet disposals to retailers by HB in 1996 were made [. . .], and account for a large proportion of the retailer-owned cabinets in the relevant market. HB's cabinet hire-purchase scheme, introduced in 1995, has not attracted the interest of any retailers (see paragraphs 70 and 71) in spite of HB's expressed conviction that its terms would prove attractive to them; only 11 % of those retailers interviewed by Lansdowne who did not already own a cabinet or have one on hire-purchase expressed interest in the HB scheme. The market research carried out by Rosslyn found that, of the 26 % of all outlets interviewed who said they would be prepared to install a replacement or additional freezer, 82 % would not be prepared to buy a cabinet themselves and 80 % would not take a non-exclusive cabinet on rent.