PGMs occur naturally together in the same ore body. In addition, they tend to be concentrated together with the ferrous metals (iron, nickel, copper, chromium and cobalt) as a result of natural geological processes. However, PGMs do not constitute a single relevant product market, but, instead, six individual markets, specifically: platinum, palladium, rhodium, iridium, ruthenium and osmium. In their notification the parties stated that PGMs 'may be combined for use in autocatalysts but are otherwise used in a variety of different applications and are not substitutable for each other, having different properties.` Furthermore, in reality substitution is limited for PGMs. As one fabricator noted:
'PGMs have many unique properties and ... complete substitution tends to take place rarely or slowly, although 'thrifting` (i.e. reducing the quantity of PGMs used per unit of production) is a regular feature of the market.`