Recital 192, Decision_act (EU) 1997/26

In forcesince 24 Apr 1996

In their reply, the parties express concern that the Commission has failed to give proper weight to the evidence in the case by giving a misleading impression of third party views of the merger. They attempt to quantify the importance of evidence by citing a percentage of responses to two particular questions included in Commission questionnaires which they believe would support their position regarding the impact of the transaction. The Commission does not agree that it is possible to evaluate the weight of this evidence by assigning percentages to the responses. In fact, it is precisely because the Commission has considered all evidence that it has concluded that the merger would reduce competition in the platinum market.

B.6. Economic analysis presented by the parties