Recital 190, Decision_act (EU) 1997/26

In forcesince 24 Apr 1996

In the absence of a merger, an expansion by LPD would increase the competitive pressure on the low-margin mining shafts of Implats and Amplats. The Commission, estimates, based on the graph in Annex II, that shafts with negative operating profits accounted for [...] (23) of Implats' production and [...] (24) of Amplats in 1994. The merger will reduce competition and create oligopolistic dominance for two reasons:

(i)

the merger will definitively remove the competitive threat of LPD to the high cost operations of Implats by consolidating the marketing functions of LPD and Implats and by ensuring that any future expansion of the current reserves of LPD is undertaken with a view to the interest of the whole of Implats/LPD. From the point of view of Implats the merger would provide a check on the competitive behaviour of the current LPD;

(ii)

the merger will create a company of the same size as Amplats, with ample low cost reserves, a similar cost structure and with an ability to exert greater influence in the market. In this situation, given the market characteristics and the past behaviour of competition in the industry, there will be no incentive for Amplats and Implats/LPD to compete with each other. Anti-competitive parallel behaviour is therefore a highly likely outcome of the merger. Indeed the current structure is much more likely to result in some degree of competition, because LPD is a third force in the market and has a higher incentive to expand its production than a merged Implats/LPD.