From 29 October 1964, Ford had submitted a number of notifications of selective distribution contracts requesting either negative clearance or an exemption pursuant to Article 85 (3). In 1982, the Commission began to receive complaints, both formal and informal, of interference on Ford's part with parallel trade in tractors from other tractor manufacturers/importers. The Commission began to investigate Ford in 1985, with a request for information under Article 11 of Regulation No 17 in January, followed by investigations pursuant to Article 14 of that Regulation in Ford's Basildon tractor plant in the UK in March, Ford's Belgian subsidiary in June and Ford's Dutch subsidiary in July of that year.
In parallel, the Commission had obtained information from other manufacturers, from trade associations and from dealers or purchasers of tractors which throw light on Ford's conduct. The Commission had already, on 11 November 1988, issued a Statement of Objections concerning a UK tractor registration exchange (ref. IV/31.370 and IV/31.466) addressed, among others, to Ford; this sought to condemn Ford for its participation in the exchange, and for the use made by the members, including Ford, for the purpose of tracing parallel imports, of the registration documents made available to the exchange by the registration authorities for its statistical purposes. In its response dated 31 January 1989 to that Statement of Objections, Ford argued that the parallel import issue had nothing to do with the activities of the exchange. Ford asked, repeating this request at the hearing held in April 1989, that the Commission treat, if indeed it planned to treat at all, the parallel import question separately with each individual company. On 12 June 1990, the Commission addressed a Statement of Objections to Ford New Holland Limited in the present case which did deal with Ford's use of registration documents, as does the present Decision (it is not, however, concerned with the operation of the exchange itself). On 31 July 1990 Ford replied to the Statement of Objections. Fiat Geotech Technologie per la Terra SpA, the new owner of Ford New Holland Limited, has since waived, by letter dated 19 September 1991, the right to an oral hearing.
Economic background