Recital 46, Decision_act (EU) 1993/9

In forcesince 30 Sep 1992

For the residential customer in particular, it is difficult to distinguish between polypropylene carpets and nylon carpets. Consumers make their buying decisions for carpets on the basis of four main criteria, these being price, colour/design, intended use, and quality. Price, however, is the most important factor generally.

Prices of carpets in general vary enormously. There are however identifiable price categories at which nylon and polypropylene carpets are sold. These vary to a certain extent from one Member State to another. Polypropylene carpets so far have been mainly sold in the lowest price category. This category also contains the cheapest nylon carpets. In the Medium price category, the carpets sold have been mainly nylon carpets but polypropylene carpets are now making inroads. In the higher price category, very few polypropylene carpets have been sold in the past.

There is therefore direct competition between polypropylene carpets and nylon carpets in the main segments of the overall carpet market. This degree of overlap at retail level results in significant indirect competitive pressure on the prices of carpet fibres. This indirect pressure amounts to a significant constraint on the competitive behaviour of the nylon fibre suppliers.

5.5. Effect of the proposed concentration on the nylon carpet fibre market (47) The Community nylon carpet fibre market is for the time being competitive. There is price competition and there is in particular competition with regard to quality and innovation. As a result of the proposed acquisition of ICI's nylon business, Du Pont would be the strongest player in the Community nylon carpet fibre market. It is true that the position of the remaining competitors, the possibilities for the carpet manufacturers to switch suppliers over time, together with the significant indirect competitive pressure from polypropylene carpets on the retail level, amount to some constraint on Du Pont's freedom of action. Nevertheless, the strengthening of Du Pont in the Community nylon carpet fibre market leads to a considerable reduction of competition, in particular with regard to the competition in product development. Product differentiation resulting from continuing innovation is one of the driving forces of this market. Competition in product development between Du Pont and ICI in the past has been an important source of innovation in the Community. Consequently, it is reasonable to assume that the position of Du Pont would be such as to enable it to act independently of its competitors and of its customers.