PART 9
ALLOCATION AND SENDING FOR TRIAL
Contents of this Part |
General rules |
When this Part applies | rule 9.1
Exercise of magistrates’ court’s powers | rule 9.2
Matters to be specified on sending for trial | rule 9.3
Duty of justices’ legal adviser | rule 9.4
Duty of magistrates’ court officer | rule 9.5
Giving and service of written notices, etc. | rule 9.6
Sending without allocation for Crown Court trial |
Prosecutor’s notice requiring Crown Court trial | rule 9.7
Sending by written procedure for Crown Court trial | rule 9.8
Sending at a hearing for Crown Court trial | rule 9.9
Allocation for trial: adult defendants |
Request by written procedure for plea indication | rule 9.10
Guilty plea indication by written procedure | rule 9.11
Not guilty plea indication by written procedure | rule 9.12
Allocation by written procedure for magistrates’ court trial | rule 9.13
Request at a hearing for plea indication | rule 9.14
Guilty plea indication at a hearing | rule 9.15
Not guilty plea indication at a hearing | rule 9.16
Allocation at a hearing for magistrates’ court trial | rule 9.17
Prosecutor’s application for Crown Court trial | rule 9.18
Allocation for trial: young defendants |
Allocation by written procedure for youth court or Crown Court trial | rule 9.19
Young defendant becoming an adult during written procedure | rule 9.20
Allocation at a hearing for youth court or Crown Court trial | rule 9.21
Young defendant becoming an adult after allocation for youth court trial | rule 9.22
Sending after allocation for Crown Court trial |
Sending after allocation for Crown Court trial | rule 9.23
Committal for sentence in connection with sending for trial |
Committal for sentence for offence related to an offence sent for trial | rule 9.24
Sending back, etc. for magistrates’ court trial |
Sending back or referring case for magistrates’ court trial | rule 9.25
GENERAL RULES
When this Part applies
9.1. (1) This Part applies to—
the allocation and sending of cases for trial under—
sections 17ZA to 26 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980, and
sections 50A to 52 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998; and
the sending back or referring of cases to a magistrates’ court for trial under—
section 46ZA of the Senior Courts Act 1981, and
paragraph 6 of Schedule 3 to the Crime and Disorder Act 1998.
Rules 9.7 to 9.9 apply in a magistrates’ court where the court must, or can, send a defendant to the Crown Court for trial without allocating the case for trial there.
Rules 9.10 to 9.23 apply in a magistrates’ court where the court must allocate the case to a magistrates’ court or to the Crown Court for trial.
Rule 9.24 applies in a magistrates’ court where, after applying other rules in this Part, the court can commit for sentence to the Crown Court a defendant who pleads guilty to an offence related to one sent for trial there.
Rule 9.25 applies in the Crown Court where the court can send back or refer a defendant to a magistrates’ court for trial.
[Note. At the first hearing in a magistrates’ court the court may (and in some cases must) order trial in that court, or may (and in some cases must) send the defendant to the Crown Court for trial under section 51 or 51A of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998. The decision depends upon—
the classification of the offence (and the general rule, subject to exceptions, is that an offence classified as triable only on indictment must be sent to the Crown Court for trial; an offence classified as triable only summarily must be tried in a magistrates’ court; and an offence classified as triable either way, on indictment or summarily, must be allocated to one or the other court for trial, subject to the defendant’s right to choose Crown Court trial: see in particular sections 50A, 51 and 51A of the 1998 Act and section 19 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980);
the defendant’s age (and the general rule, subject to exceptions, is that an offence alleged against a defendant under 18 must be tried in a magistrates’ court sitting as a youth court: see in particular sections 24 and 24A of the 1980 Act);
whether the defendant is awaiting Crown Court trial for another offence;
whether another defendant, charged with the same or a connected offence, is awaiting Crown Court trial for that offence;
in some cases (destroying or damaging property; aggravated vehicle taking), whether the value involved is more or less than £5,000; and
in a case of low-value shoplifting, whether the defendant chooses Crown Court trial: see section 22A of the 1980 Act.
A magistrates’ court’s powers of sending and allocation, including its powers (i) to receive a defendant’s indication of an intention to plead guilty and (ii) to give an indication of likely sentence, may be exercised by a single justice: see sections 51(13) and 51A(11) of the 1998 Act, and sections 17E, 18(5) and 24D of the 1980 Act.
The circumstances in which the Crown Court can send back or refer a case for magistrates’ court trial are summarised in the note to rule 9.25.]
Exercise of magistrates’ court’s powers
9.2. (1) This rule applies to the exercise of a magistrates’ court’s powers to which this Part applies.
Where the court considers the case of a defendant charged with two or more offences the court must deal with those offences in the following sequence (and the court may ask the defendant questions to help it decide with which offence to begin)—
any to which rule 9.7 applies (Prosecutor’s notice requiring Crown Court trial);
any to which rule 9.8 or rule 9.9 applies (sending for Crown Court trial without allocation there), in this sequence—
any one or more that the court must send for trial because of section 51(1) or section 51A(A1) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (which set out the principal conditions for sending for trial an adult or a young defendant respectively),
any the court must send for trial under paragraph (3) or (4) of this rule, and
any the court may send for trial under paragraph (4) of this rule; and
any to which rule 9.23 applies (Sending after allocation for Crown Court trial).
Where the court on the same or separate occasions considers the cases of two or more defendants charged jointly with an offence, if the court sends one of those defendants to the Crown Court for trial for that offence—
on the same occasion the court must so send each other defendant so charged even if by then the court has decided to allocate that other defendant for magistrates’ court trial; and
on a subsequent occasion the court may so send another defendant so charged; but
where a jointly charged defendant is under 18—
unless the jointly charged offence is one that falls within section 51A(12) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (homicide and certain offences involving weapons), before the court sends that defendant to the Crown Court for that offence the court must take a plea indication from that defendant under section 24A of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980 (or section 24B of that Act, where that applies) and deal with the defendant accordingly, and
if the defendant indicates a not guilty plea then the court may send that defendant for Crown Court trial only if the court considers it necessary in the interests of justice to do so.
Subject to paragraph (3) (jointly charged defendants), where the court sends a defendant whose case it is considering to the Crown Court for trial for an offence because of section 51(1) or section 51A(A1) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (in this rule, ‘a lead offence’)—
on the same occasion as that sending the court must send that defendant to the Crown Court for trial for any other indictable or summary offence with which that defendant is charged (in this rule, ‘a connected offence’)—
if the circumstances of that other offence appear to the court to be the same as, or connected with, those giving rise to a lead offence, and
where the connected offence is a summary offence, if it is one to which section 40 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 applies (specified summary offences founded on the prosecution evidence), or one which is punishable with imprisonment, or one which involves obligatory or discretionary disqualification from driving, but
where the defendant is under 18, only if the court considers it necessary in the interests of justice to do so;
on the same occasion as that sending, if another defendant whose case the court is considering is charged with a connected offence then the court must send that other defendant to the Crown Court for trial for that offence, subject to paragraph (4)(d) if it applies;
on an occasion subsequent to that sending the court may send any defendant whose case it is considering to the Crown Court for trial for a connected offence with which that defendant is charged, subject to paragraph (4)(d) if it applies; and
where a defendant to whom paragraph (4)(b) or (4)(c) refers is under 18 then—
a connected offence for which that defendant is sent for trial must be an indictable offence,
unless the connected offence is one that falls within section 51A(12) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (homicide and certain offences involving weapons), before the court sends that defendant to the Crown Court for that offence the court must take a plea indication from that defendant under section 24A of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980 (or section 24B of that Act, where that applies) and deal with the defendant accordingly, and
if the defendant indicates a not guilty plea then the court may send that defendant for Crown Court trial only if the court considers it necessary in the interests of justice to do so.
The court must require the defendant to provide or confirm the defendant’s name and date of birth in response to a notice served on the defendant under—
rule 9.8(3) (Sending by written procedure for Crown Court trial);
rule 9.10(2) (Request by written procedure for plea indication); or
rule 9.19(2) (Allocation by written procedure for youth court or Crown Court trial).
At a hearing, the court—
must, as a general rule, exercise its powers in public, but it may exercise any power it has to—
withhold information from the public, or
order a hearing in private; and
may exercise its power to adjourn—
if either party asks, or
on its own initiative.
At a hearing the general rule is that the court must exercise its powers in the defendant’s presence (which presence may be by live link or through a legal representative), but it may exercise the powers to which the following rules apply in the defendant’s absence on the conditions specified—
where rule 9.9 (Sending at a hearing for Crown Court trial) applies, after following the procedure in rule 9.8 (Sending by written procedure for Crown Court trial);
where rule 9.14 (Request at a hearing for plea indication), rule 9.16 (Not guilty plea indication at a hearing) or rule 9.17 (Allocation for magistrates’ court trial at a hearing) applies, if the court is satisfied that it is not contrary to the interests of justice to proceed in the defendant’s absence and—
the defendant’s legal representative is present and either that representative tells the court that the defendant agrees to it proceeding in the defendant’s absence or the court does not consider that there is an acceptable reason for the defendant’s failure to attend,
either the court is satisfied that the defendant had reasonable notice of the hearing or the defendant has attended a previous hearing in the case and in either case the court does not consider that there is an acceptable reason for the defendant’s failure to attend, or
the defendant’s disorderly conduct at the hearing makes it impracticable to proceed in the defendant’s presence;
where rule 9.21 (Allocation at a hearing for youth court or Crown Court trial) applies, when the court asks the defendant for a plea indication, guilty or not guilty, if—
the defendant’s legal representative is present,
the defendant’s disorderly conduct at the hearing makes it impracticable to proceed in the defendant’s presence, and
the court considers that it should proceed in the defendant’s absence;
where rule 9.21 (Allocation at a hearing for youth court or Crown Court trial) applies, after the court asks the defendant for a plea indication if—
the defendant has given no notice of plea indication under rule 9.19 (Allocation by written procedure for youth court or Crown Court trial),
either the court is satisfied that the defendant had reasonable notice of the hearing or the defendant has attended a previous hearing in the case and in either case the court does not consider that there is an acceptable reason for the defendant’s failure to attend, and
the court is satisfied that it is not contrary to the interests of justice to proceed in the defendant’s absence; and
where rule 9.24 (Committal for sentence for offence related to an offence sent for trial) applies, unless—
it appears to the court to be contrary to the interests of justice to do so, and
the court considers that there is an acceptable reason for the defendant’s absence.
Where the defendant is under 18—
if rule 9.8 or rule 9.19 applies (Sending by written procedure for Crown Court trial; Allocation by written procedure for youth court or Crown Court trial), unless the court is satisfied that it would be unreasonable to do so having regard to the circumstances of the case the court may, in any case, and where the defendant is under 16 the court must—
ask whether a parent or guardian of the defendant is aware of the written proceedings, and
if that may not be so then serve on at least one such person the notices, explanations and requests required by whichever of those rules applies;
if the defendant gives notice of a guilty or not guilty plea under rule 9.19, unless the court is satisfied that it would be unreasonable to do so having regard to the circumstances of the case the court may, in any case, and where the defendant is under 16 the court must—
ask whether a parent or guardian of the defendant is aware of that, and
if that may not be so then serve on at least one such person notice that the defendant has given that plea indication; and
if there is to be a hearing, unless the court is satisfied that it would be unreasonable to do so having regard to the circumstances of the case—
the court must require a parent or guardian of the defendant to attend where the defendant is under 16, and
may require such a person to attend where the defendant is over 16.
[Note. See sections 47, 50A, 51, 51A and 52 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and sections 17A, 17B, 17BA, 17C, 18, 23, 24A, 24B, 24BA and 24C of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980.
Under sections 51(3A), (3B) and 51A(4A), (4B) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, Criminal Procedure Rules may make provision about situations where a defendant is sent to the Crown Court for trial for an alleged offence and any other offence is, or appears to be, related (in such a way as is specified in the Rules) to that alleged offence.
Under section 51 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, the court may require a defendant to attend by live link a hearing to which this Part applies.
Part 46 contains rules allowing a representative to act on a defendant’s behalf for the purposes of these Rules. Rules 9.8 and 9.17 set out procedures that apply where neither the defendant nor the defendant’s legal representative attends a hearing to which those rules apply.
Where a defendant waives the right to be present then the court may nonetheless require his or her attendance by summons or warrant: see section 26 of the 1980 Act.
Under section 52A of the 1998 Act, reporting restrictions apply to the proceedings to which rules 9.7 to 9.23 apply.
Under section 86A of the Courts Act 2003, Criminal Procedure Rules must specify stages of proceedings at which the court must require the information listed in rule 9.2(5) and may specify other stages of proceedings when such requirements may be imposed. A person commits an offence if, without reasonable excuse, that person fails to comply with such a requirement, whether by providing false or incomplete information or by providing no information.
Section 34A of the Children and Young Persons Act 1933 allows, and in some circumstances requires, the court to notify a parent or guardian and require their attendance.
Section 40 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 lists summary offences which may be included in an indictment if the charge—
is founded on the same facts or evidence as a count charging an indictable offence; or
is part of a series of offences of the same or similar character as an indictable offence which is also charged.
Part 3 contains rules about the court’s powers of case management.]
Matters to be specified on sending for trial
9.3. (1) Where the court sends a defendant to the Crown Court for trial, it must specify—
each offence to be tried;
in respect of each, the power exercised to send the defendant for trial for that offence; and
the Crown Court centre at which the trial will take place.
In a case in which the prosecutor serves a notice to which rule 9.7(1)(a) applies (notice requiring Crown Court trial in a case of serious or complex fraud), the court must specify the Crown Court centre identified by that notice.
In any other case, in deciding the Crown Court centre at which the trial will take place, the court must take into account—
the convenience of the parties and witnesses;
how soon a suitable courtroom will be available; and
the directions on the allocation of Crown Court business contained in the Practice Direction.
[Note. See section 51D of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998.]
Duty of justices’ legal adviser
9.4. (1) This rule applies—
only in a magistrates’ court; and
unless the court—
includes a District Judge (Magistrates’ Courts), and
otherwise directs.
On the court’s behalf, a justices’ legal adviser may—
read the allegation of the offence to the defendant; and
give any explanation and ask any question required by the rules in this Part.
[Note. For the functions of a justices’ legal adviser, see sections 28 and 29 of the Courts Act 2003. See also rule 2.12 (Duties of justices’ legal adviser).]
Duty of magistrates’ court officer
9.5. (1) The magistrates’ court officer must—
notify the prosecutor of the defendant’s withdrawal of a notice given under rule 9.11, 9.12 or 9.19 (written notices of plea indication);
make available to the Crown Court officer and give to or serve on the parties notice of a sending for Crown Court trial under rule 9.8, 9.9 or 9.23;
in such a notice of sending include—
the matters specified by the court under rule 9.3 (Matters to be specified on sending for trial),
…
any indication given by the defendant under rule 9.8 or 9.9 of intended guilty plea,
any decision by the defendant under rule 9.12 or 9.16 to require Crown Court trial (not guilty plea indication by written procedure or at a hearing),
any indication of likely sentence to which rule 9.11 or rule 9.13 applies,
any decision by the defendant under rule 9.13 or 9.17 to decline magistrates’ court trial (allocation for magistrates’ court trial by written procedure or at a hearing),
any opinion stated by the court under rule 9.24 (Committal for sentence of offence related to an offence sent for trial), and
the date on which any custody time limit will expire; and
give the court such other assistance as it requires.
The magistrates’ court officer must make available to the Crown Court officer—
the initial details of the prosecution case served by the prosecutor under rule 8.2;
any information supplied by the parties for the purposes of case management by the court;
a record of any—
listing or case management direction affecting the Crown Court,
direction about reporting restrictions,
decision about bail, for the purposes of section 5 of the Bail Act 1976,
recognizance given by a surety, or
representation order; and
if relevant, any available details of any—
interpreter,
intermediary, or
other supporting adult, where the defendant is assisted by such a person.
[Note. See sections 51, 51A and 51D of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, and section 20A of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980.]
Giving and service of written notices, etc.
9.6. (1) In this rule “the written procedure rules” means rules 9.8, 9.10 to 9.13, 9.19 and 9.20.
The notices, explanations and warnings required by the following rules must be served on the defendant—
rule 9.8(3) (Sending by written procedure for Crown Court trial);
rule 9.10(2) (Request by written procedure for plea indication); and
rule 9.19(2) (Allocation by written procedure for youth court or Crown Court trial).
Paragraph (4) applies to—
notices, explanations, warnings and requests required, and responses invited, under the written procedure rules other than those to which paragraph (2) refers;
any withdrawal by a defendant of a plea indication given under rule 9.11, 9.12 or 9.19; and
any written notice, explanation, warning or request required, and any written response invited, under rule 9.23 (Sending after allocation for Crown Court trial).
Where this paragraph applies the communication must be—
given by means of such electronic arrangements as have been made for the purposes of rule 5.1 (Applications, etc. by forms or electronic means); or
served if, but only if—
no such electronic arrangements have been made, or
the recipient has not used such arrangements in response to an invitation to do so.
[Note. Each of rules 9.8(3), 9.10(2) and 9.19(2) requires a notice inviting the defendant to take part in a written procedure using electronic means.]
SENDING WITHOUT ALLOCATION FOR CROWN COURT TRIAL
Prosecutor’s notice requiring Crown Court trial
9.7. (1) This rule applies where a prosecutor with power to do so requires a magistrates’ court to send for trial in the Crown Court—
a case of serious or complex fraud; or
a case which will involve a child witness.
The prosecutor must serve notice of that requirement—
on the magistrates’ court officer and on the defendant; and
before trial in a magistrates’ court begins under Part 24 (Trial and sentence in a magistrates’ court).
The notice must identify—
the power on which the prosecutor relies; and
the Crown Court centre at which the prosecutor wants the trial to take place.
The prosecutor—
must, when choosing a Crown Court centre, take into account the matters listed in rule 9.3(3) (court deciding to which Crown Court centre to send a case); and
may change the centre identified before the case is sent for trial.