On 15 January 2025, Ukraine submitted a request for payment of the third instalment of the Ukraine Plan, in accordance with Article 26 of Regulation (EU) 2024/792 of 29 February 2024 establishing the Ukraine Facility [Regulation (EU) 2024/792 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 February 2024 establishing the Ukraine Facility, OJ L, 2024/792, 29.2.2024, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/792/oj.]. To support the payment request, Ukraine provided justification of the satisfactory fulfilment of all 13 steps set out in the Annex to Council Implementing Decision 2024/1447 of 14 May 2024 on the approval of the assessment of the Ukraine Plan (the CID Annex) [Council Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/1447 of 14 May 2024 on the approval of the assessment of the Ukraine Plan, OJ L, 2024/1447, 24.5.2024, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dec_impl/2024/1447/oj. The Annex to the Council Implementing Decision is available at: https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST-9492-2024-ADD-1/en/pdf].
Based on the information provided by Ukraine, all 13 steps are considered satisfactorily fulfilled.
As part of chapter C.2 on public financial management, the strategic plan for digitalisation of the state tax service has been adopted. As part of chapter C.3 on the judicial system, legislation on the improvement of insolvency regime has entered into force. As part of chapter C.6 on management of public assets, the state ownership policy has been adopted, and the triage of state-owned enterprises has been completed. As part of chapter C.7 on human capital, both the strategy for reforming psychoneurological and other residential institutions, and for the de-institutionalisation of care for persons with disabilities and older persons; and the children strategy have been adopted. As part of chapter C.8 on business environment, the resolution for the resumption of market surveillance measures and control of non-food products has been adopted. As part of chapter C.9 on decentralisation and regional policies, the resolutions for the development of urban planning at local level have been adopted. As part of chapter C.10 on energy, a market-based framework for renewable energy has been introduced and the legislation to ensure the independence of the National Energy Utilities Regulatory Commission has entered into force. As part of chapter C.11 on transport, the revised national transport strategy has been adopted and the strategy for developing and expanding the border infrastructure with EU Member States and the Republic of Moldova has been adopted. As part of chapter C.12 on agri-food sector, the strategy for agriculture and rural development has been adopted and the legislation on the State Agrarian Register has entered into force. As part of chapter C.13 on management of critical raw materials, the legislation revising the national programme for the development of the mineral resource base has entered into force.
Name of the step: Adoption of the strategic plan for digitalisation of the State Tax Service
Related reform/investment: Reform 1. Improved revenue management
Financed from: loans
The requirement for Step 2.1 described in the CID Annex is:
‘Adoption of the strategic plan for digital development, digital transformation and digitalization of State Tax Service of Ukraine, in line with the recommendations of the National Revenue Strategy for 2024-2030.’
Step 2.1 is the second step in the implementation of Reform 1 of Chapter 2 (public financial management). It was preceded by Step 2.2 (adoption of the strategic plan for the digitalisation of the state customs service), which was positively assessed in Q2 2024.
summary document duly justifying how the step was satisfactorily fulfilled in line with the requirements set out in the CID Annex;
copy of Order of the Ministry of Finance No 660 ‘On the implementation of the Decision of the Committee on Information Technology Management in the Public Financial Management System’, dated 24 December 2024;
copy of the ‘Strategic plan for digitalisation of the State Tax Service of Ukraine up to 2030’ as an attachment to Order of the Ministry of Finance No 660 of 24 December 2024.
The justification and substantive evidence provided by the Ukrainian authorities cover all the constitutive elements of Step 2.1.
The objective of Reform 1 of Chapter 2 (public financial management) is to enhance domestic revenue mobilisation by improving the efficiency and effectiveness of the tax and customs administrations. To this end, the Ministry of Finance adopted the Strategic plan for the digitalisation of the State Tax Service of Ukraine up to 2030 through Order No 660 of 24 December 2024. The objective of the strategic plan is to strengthen the tax administration’s functioning and service provision capacity by upgrading its digital infrastructure ecosystem.
The strategic plan sets out the key priorities and associated projects for the digital development of the State Tax Service, in line with the Tax Code of Ukraine and the National Revenue Strategy for 2024-2030. The key priorities are to: (i) enhance taxpayer compliance; (ii) promote transparency; (iii) improve data quality and governance; (iv) align its digital systems with the EU’s digital systems; and (v) strengthen data security. The plan identifies 26 projects to be carried out over the next five years to help achieve the priorities set. These projects seek either to improve existing IT systems or to introduce new ones.
To enhance taxpayer compliance and increase the overall tax base, the plan envisages the introduction of an automated risk-based management and audit system designed to identify high-risk taxpayers and assess non-compliance risks. It also envisages improvements in the electronic pre-filling of tax returns to facilitate tax reporting. To promote transparency, an information management system will be introduced to provide real-time data on taxpayers’ tax status. Setting up a single electronic warehouse for data storage should improve data quality, governance and use. Integration with the VAT Information Exchange System (VIES) and the Excise Movement and Control System (EMCS) should help Ukraine further align its digital systems with the EU’s digital systems.
The strategic plan includes a revision clause to ensure alignment with potential developments at EU level regarding digital systems in the field of tax administration, including VIES and EMCS.
Commission assessment: satisfactorily fulfilled
Name of the step: Entry into force of the legislation on the improvement of the insolvency regime
Related reform/investment: Reform 2. Reforms of insolvency and enforcement of court decisions
Financed from: non-repayable support
The requirement for Step 3.6 described in the CID Annex is:
‘Entry into force of the law on the improvement of insolvency regime and the relevant secondary legislation, introducing insolvency prevention system and the early warning tool for legal entities and entrepreneurs in line with the principles of Directive (EU) 2019/1023 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2019 on preventive restructuring frameworks, on discharge of debt and disqualifications, and on measures to increase the efficiency of procedures concerning restructuring, insolvency and discharge of debt, and amending Directive (EU) 2017/1132. The new legislation focuses on these main areas:
prevention of bankruptcy and restoration of solvency of debtors
early detection of signs of crisis in the company
identification of additional opportunities for restoring solvency of companies
availability of information for the companies about the mechanisms for preventing insolvency and early warning.’
Step 3.6 is the first of the five steps in the implementation of Reform 2 of Chapter 3 (judicial system). It is followed by Step 3.8 (due by Q2 2025) on improving the enforcement of court decisions; Step 3.9 (due by Q4 2025) on the data collection system on enforcement of decisions; Step 3.7 (due by Q1 2026) on simplifying insolvency proceedings for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs); and Step 3.10 (due by Q2 2026) on upgrading the IT system for the enforcement of court decisions.
1) summary document duly justifying how the step was satisfactory fulfilled in line with the requirements set out in the CID Annex;
2) copy of Law of Ukraine No 3985-IX ‘On Amendments to the Code of Ukraine on Bankruptcy Procedures and Other Legislative Acts of Ukraine regarding the Implementation of Directive 2019/1023 of the European Parliament and of the Council of the European Union and the Introduction of Preventive Restructuring Procedures’, dated 19 September 2024;
3) copy of Law of Ukraine of No 4114-IX ‘On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on the Priority Right of Certain Categories of Internally Displaced Persons to Receive Compensation for the Objects of Destroyed Real Estate’, dated 4 December 2024;
4) copy of Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine No 1424 ‘On Amendments to the Regulation of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and Revocation of Certain Resolutions of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on Bankruptcy’, dated 13 December 2024;
5) copy of Order of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine No 3710/5 ‘On Approval of the Procedure for Collecting, Summarizing and Posting Statistical Information on the Procedures for Preventive Restructuring, Bankruptcy and Insolvency of an Individual on the Website of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine’, dated 23 December 2024;
6) copy of Order of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine No 3734/5 ‘On Approval of the Standard Forms of the Preventive Restructuring Plan for Microenterprises and Small Businesses and the Agreement with the Preventive Restructuring Administrator’, dated 25 December 2024;
7) copy of Order of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine No 3733/5 ‘On Amendments to the Lists of Mandatory Issues for Training of Persons Intending to Carry Out Activities of Insolvency Practitioners for Training of Insolvency Practitioners in Bankruptcy Cases of Non-Bank Financial Institutions and in Bankruptcy Cases of State-Owned Enterprises and Business Associations in the Authorized Capital of which more than 50 % of Shares (Stakes) are Owned by the State’, dated 25 December 2024.
The justification and substantive evidence provided by the Ukrainian authorities cover all the constitutive elements of Step 3.6.
The Ukrainian parliament adopted Law No 3985-IX on 19 September 2024. On 4 December 2024, it adopted Law No 4114-IX amending the date of entry into force of the Law’s provisions. Based on this amendment, the Law entered into force on 1 January 2025 and the relevant secondary legislation followed between 4 December 2024 and 1 January 2025.
Law No 3985-IX introduces a system of insolvency prevention and early warning tools for legal entities and entrepreneurs in line with the principles of Directive (EU) 2019/1023 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2019 on preventive restructuring frameworks, on discharge of debt and disqualifications, and on measures to increase the efficiency of procedures concerning restructuring, insolvency and discharge of debt, and amending Directive (EU) 2017/1132. The system introduced by the Law enables the prevention of bankruptcy and the restoration of solvency for debtors. This includes in particular: (i) the identification and reporting of insolvency risks; (ii) a clear process for opening and resolving a preventive restructuring procedure; (iii) clear and comprehensive requirements for restructuring plans; (iv) the appointment of an insolvency practitioner; (v) a requirement for debtors to prove a business’s viability; (vi) implementation of a creditors’ best interest test; (vii) debtor protection measures (including suspension of enforcement actions); (viii) a cross-class ‘cram-down’ mechanism for settling creditors’ claims; (ix) protection of workers’ interests; and (x) simplification of procedure for micro, small and medium-sized enterprises.
The Law allows for early detection of signs of crisis in a company. This includes a legal obligation for auditors, accountants and the management of a company to notify debtors of any signs or threats of insolvency. The Ministry of Justice of Ukraine is required to make available on its website information on the procedure and instruments for the early warning of insolvency risks. The secondary legislation updates the mandatory training requirements for insolvency practitioners to include preventive restructuring, with the objective of raising awareness of the procedure and promoting its use. The Law enables the identification and implementation of additional opportunities for restoring the solvency of companies. This includes additional debtor protection measures for interim financing, for reprofiling liabilities and for new financing and capital raising measures as part of the restructuring plan.
Commission assessment: satisfactorily fulfilled
Name of the step: Adoption of the state ownership policy and of the triage of state-owned enterprises
Related reform/investment: Reform 1. Adopting a State Ownership Policy
Financed from: loans
The requirement for Step 6.1 described in the CID Annex is:
‘Adoption and publication of the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on Approving the General State Ownership Policy and the “triage of SOEs”. The State Ownership Policy focuses on these main areas:
listing the public policy objectives that SOEs are required to achieve;
describing the state’s role in the governance of SOEs; how the state will implement its ownership policy; and the respective roles and responsibilities of those government authorities involved in its implementation;
defining the overall rationales for keeping SOEs under state ownership and subjects these rationales to regular reviews;
setting long-term and whole-of-government priorities of SOEs ownership;
defining dividend policy, remuneration policy for members of supervisory boards and managers.
The ownership policy allows for the implementation of OECD Corporate governance reforms in DSO companies to improve competition in natural gas markets.
The triage of SOEs leads to the following outcomes:
a list of SOEs that will remain in state ownership as strategic;
a list of SOEs that will be proposed for privatisation, also indicating all SOEs which are temporarily banned for privatisation during the martial law in a dedicated subsection;
a list of SOEs which will be liquidated.’
Step 6.1 is the only step in the implementation of Reform 1 of Chapter 6 (management of public assets).
1) summary document duly justifying how the step was satisfactory fulfilled in line with the requirements set out in the CID Annex;
2) copy of Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers No 1369 on ‘Adoption of the State Ownership Policy, remuneration policy for members of state-owned enterprises supervisory boards and their managers, the state dividend policy’, dated 29 November 2024;
3) copy of the ‘State Ownership Policy, remuneration policy for members of state-owned enterprises supervisory boards and their managers, the state dividend policy’ as an attachment to the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers No 1369 dated 29 November 2024;
4) copy of Protocol No 122 Decision 2.6 on ‘Approval of the Action Plan for the State Ownership Policy’, dated 29 November 2024;
5) copy of the ‘Action Plan for the State Ownership Policy’ as an attachment to the Protocol No 122 Decision 2.6 dated 29 November 2024;
6) copy of Protocol No 135 Decision 6.1 on the ‘Approval of triage of state-owned enterprises’, dated 27 December 2024;
7) copy of extract from the Protocol No 9 of the Cabinet of Minister meeting of 24 January 2025 taking note of the ‘roadmap for the reform of corporate governance of gas distribution system operators, developed by the Ministry of Energy’.
The justification and substantive evidence provided by the Ukrainian authorities cover all the constitutive elements of Step 6.1.
The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine adopted the State Ownership Policy (the SOP) on 29 November 2024. This is a comprehensive document that defines the role of the state in the management of state-owned enterprises (SOEs). According to its provisions, the document has to be mandatorily revised within one year of being approved and at least every five years thereafter.
The SOP identifies a set of public policy objectives for SOEs to contribute to, such as the providing goods and services to satisfy citizens’ needs and contribution to sustainable economic development and social welfare. SOEs are also expected to contribute to environmental protection, energy efficiency and digitalisation.
Ukrainian primary law sets out the main responsibilities of government entities in the management of SOEs. The SOP further describes the roles of government bodies and relevant stakeholders such as the Anti-Monopoly Committee and the State Property Fund in the different processes relating to the management of state property. A detailed attribution of responsibilities is included (e.g. for triage operations, privatisation, application of corporate governance principles and assessment of SOEs’ performances). In the triage, the Ministry of Economy coordinates line ministries and stakeholders’ inputs for the preparation of the triage, while the Cabinet of Ministers is responsible for its formal approval and endorsement. The Ukrainian parliament is also consulted on the approval of the list of SOEs to be kept under state ownership. The SOP also describes the role of the Ministry of Finance throughout the process.
The SOP sets out the overall rationale and objectives for keeping SOEs under state control. It refers to the risk of market failures and natural monopolies as well as the need to ensure national security and defence considerations. SOEs’ management entities need to demonstrate their compliance with the goals and reasons set out in the SOP in order to keep the enterprise under state control.
The SOP sets out the long-term and whole-of-government priorities for SOE ownership, ensuring proper management of state property. This includes the formulation of transparency and reporting requirements for SOEs; procedures and objectives for assessing SOEs’ activities; and procedures for ensuring compliance with competitive neutrality and the corporate governance regime. The document further sets the objectives concerning the management of state property during martial law, with the specific short-term objective of ensuring national security.
Together with the State Ownership Policy, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine adopted a remuneration policy for members of supervisory boards of SOEs and their managers, and a state dividend policy. The remuneration policy prescribes a more uniform approach across different SOEs. The state dividend policy lays down general principles for determining the size and payment of SOEs’ dividends to the state budget.
The SOP includes a commitment for Ukraine to implement OECD corporate governance reforms in Distribution System Operators (DSOs) in order to improve competition in natural gas markets. To further develop this commitment, the Cabinet of Ministers took note of a roadmap for establishing a separate and independent legal entity with an independent supervisory board managing DSOs, following corporate governance principles.
The SOP also sets out the steps in the triage process. On this basis, the Cabinet of Ministries has formally adopted the SOEs triage. This includes: (i) the list of the SOEs to be kept under state ownership; (ii) the list of SOEs whose privatisation is suspended during martial law; and (iii) the list of SOEs whose property will be placed under the control of the State Property Fund for either privatisation or liquidation. As defined in the SOP, the State Property Fund will then draw up two separate lists, one for SOEs subject to privatisation and one for those subject to liquidation.
Commission assessment: satisfactorily fulfilled
Name of the step: Adoption of the Strategy for reforming Psychoneurological, Other residential Institutions and De-institutionalisation of Care for Persons with Disabilities, and older Persons and of the Strategy for Enduring the Right of Every Child in Ukraine to Grow Up in a family Environment for 2024-2028
Related reform/investment: Reform 5. Improved social infrastructure and de-institutionalisation
Financed from: loans
The requirement for Step 7.5 described in the CID Annex is:
‘Adoption of the Order of the Cabinet of Ministers “On Approval of the Strategy for Reforming Psychoneurological, Other Residential Institutions and De-institutionalisation of Care for Persons with Disabilities and Older Persons” and of the Order of the Cabinet of Ministers “On Approval of the Strategy for ensuring the right of every child in Ukraine to grow up in a family environment for 2024-2028”. The strategies focus on these main areas:
development of social services to support families with children, people with disabilities and older persons to live independently in the community and prevent institutionalisation;
development of assisted living services for people with disabilities and older people who need additional support;
providing family-based forms of upbringing (e.g. foster care, guardianship, and adoption) for children left without parental care.’
Step 7.5 is the only step in the implementation of Reform 5 of Chapter 7 (human capital).
1) summary document duly justifying how the step was satisfactorily fulfilled in line with the requirements set out in the CID Annex;
2) copy of Order No 1355-r of the Cabinet of Ministers on the approval of the ‘Strategy for the Reform of Psychoneurological and Other Residential Institutions and Deinstitutionalization of Care for Adults with Disabilities and the Elderly up to 2034’, as well as the ‘Operational Plan of Measures for Its Implementation in 2025-2027’, both dated 24 December 2024;
3) copy of Decree No 1201 of the Cabinet of Ministers on the approval of the ‘Strategy for ensuring the right of every child in Ukraine to grow up in a family environment for the years 2024–2028’, as well as the ‘Operational Plan of Measures for its Implementation for the Years 2024–2026’, both dated 26 November 2024.
The justification and substantive evidence provided by the Ukrainian authorities cover all the constitutive elements of Step 7.5.
‘The Strategy for Ensuring the Right of Every Child to Grow Up in a Family Environment for 2024-2028’ was adopted on 26 November 2024 by the Cabinet of Ministers along with the operational plan of action for its implementation for 2024-2026.