Second, the applicant took the view that the Commission’s reasoning is inadequate to conclude the existence of significant distortions in China. In the applicant’s opinion, the Commission failed to demonstrate the actual existence of governmental intervention and/or its distortive effect on the price and cost of production of the product under review. In this respect, (i) the applicant referred to the Appellate Body’s reasoning in US – Countervailing Measures (China), according to which ‘the existence of price distortion resulting from government intervention has to be established and adequately explained’ and ‘the determination must be made on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the characteristics of the market being examined’; (ii) the applicant considered that the Commission misinterpreted the nature of (the 14th) FYP which, according to the applicant, should be merely read as a guidance document not complemented by compulsory national instruments or punishments for producers failing to comply with the FYP’s objectives; (iii) the applicant argued that the Commission also misrepresented the position and power of the CCP organization in the daily management of a company, since the CCP organization does not play a role in the decision-making processes even if the members of the CCP organization and board members may overlap.
86 3. RESULTS OF THE INVESTIGATION › 3.2. Dumping › 3.2.2. Normal value › 3.2.2.1. Existence of significant distortions › 3.2.2.1.9. Systemic nature of the distortions described, Regulation (EU) 2023/2180
In forcesince 16 Oct 2023